By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - VGC Mafia Round -28- FullMetal Alchemist

TruckOSaurus said:

I'm kinda bummed that we have to turn to lurker lynching but I don't have any other leads right now.

There's something I do wanna talk about though:

Is there still people who believe we're dealing with a Vigilante instead of a Serial Killer? Because to me the vigilante option makes no sense whatsoever.

- First because that Vigilante would have to be pretty stupid.

- Second because although he was lurking, I don't see any pro-town reasoning that would lead to choosing to off him.

- Third because Arsonist as always been an anti-town role.

Now if someone has some info (maybe from the theme of the game) that would make it possible for a Vigilante to be our arsonist, please share it with me. If not I think we should accept that whoever killed Vetteman is anti-town.

We've twice already given info from the theme of the game that would fit a Vig being responsible for the kill, but it's impossible to know alignment here even it was a good guy in FMA. Now, I do have to admit SK is quite likely given the evidence against the kill being Vig.



Around the Network
theprof00 said:

If there's anyone I want to vote for besides trash, it's Baal. I don't trust everything he's saying, and more importantly, I don't like that Heph is defending him. There's just no reason for it outside of being a cop and scanning him innocent and yaknow, even so, there's nothing saying that Baal isn't a godfather, or that Heph is an insane cop or something.

And I know for a fact that there aren't any masons.

There is literally no reason why Baal should be trusted. The only thing that keeps stopping me is that I keep thinking that he's a noob and deserves a break, and just might be a lot smarter than I'm currently giving him credit for. No offense, Baal. You just haven't proven yourself yet, to me at least.

How do you know that?



theprof00 said:

Ok, so I just watched an episode, episode 8, in the scene where Hughes says to the colonel "get yourself a wife" and it said scar was an SK... Like, those words exactly.

I can't help but think hatmoza is fucking with me somehow.

I'm pretty sure if ABC was SK he'd lose his kill for tonight with the nameclaim. But Scar doesn't fit for a burn kill, for the majority of either anime he only did the deconstructing part of alchemy without reconstructing elements to form new things.



tracking...



theprof00 said:

I've figured out more than you know. I just don't go blabbing on and on about it.

And don't be surprised with Heph. He's a phenom.

 

theprof00 said:

 I'm really REALLY interested to know how two people beside Baal seem so confident in what he is.

Of course, if they come out so directly like this, they can't possibly be mafia. What am I not getting here?

I hope at some point you will be able to point out what you had figured out at the time of the first quote. As for Baal, I have an idea as well, but it doesn't fit with his statement that he'd lose the ability for the entire length of the game. Doesn't matter though as the Baal issue, like ABC's early claim would have before revealing additional info, will be solved on a later night/day.



Around the Network
theprof00 said:
Final-Fan said:

And now -- sorry for all the posts -- I'm wondering, prof, what has YOU so sure he's lying, so that you want to lynch him. 


because he said I'm going to call him a genius.

seriously though, why come out and say anything at all? Why not let the town think there is an SK for a couple days? Even so, if you can't bear for the town to get all crazy, figure out a way to guide the town towards vig. It just doesn't look like a town plan of action.

Similarly to Abc's "someone visited me last night". I only trust them because I trust one or two other players and I've been wondering if that trust is misplaced.

 

theprof00 said:

 On top of that, he said, "you can lynch me tomorrow". Think about the implications.

Both the "genius" and  "lynch me tomorrow" quotes came AFTER you already voted him.



Anyway, I'd like to lynch Stefl so I'll make that known.

Vote: Stefl1504
Unvote

There's not a whole lot from him to actually push for a lynch though. I'm not liking NotStan either. I have a feeling FF or TOS is scum, and leaning towards the latter.(Jeez TOS is always scum!) That's not a good feeling to act on though so I'll look into each more.

It's not going to provide much information, but the trashleg lynch seems to have been decided for today. The lynch could be used to prove someone, I'm just trying to think if there's any reason not to do it.



Linkzmax said:

Anyway, I'd like to lynch Stefl so I'll make that known.

Vote: Stefl1504
Unvote

There's not a whole lot from him to actually push for a lynch though. I'm not liking NotStan either. I have a feeling FF or TOS is scum, and leaning towards the latter.(Jeez TOS is always scum!) That's not a good feeling to act on though so I'll look into each more.

It's not going to provide much information, but the trashleg lynch seems to have been decided for today. The lynch could be used to prove someone, I'm just trying to think if there's any reason not to do it.


The lynch of trash is by no means set.



Linkzmax said:

Anyway, I'd like to lynch Stefl so I'll make that known.

Vote: Stefl1504
Unvote

There's not a whole lot from him to actually push for a lynch though. I'm not liking NotStan either. I have a feeling FF or TOS is scum, and leaning towards the latter.(Jeez TOS is always scum!) That's not a good feeling to act on though so I'll look into each more.

It's not going to provide much information, but the trashleg lynch seems to have been decided for today. The lynch could be used to prove someone, I'm just trying to think if there's any reason not to do it.

What was the purpose of voting and then unvoting, I don't really understand that.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

It's easier to see who I suspect in properly kept votals than hunting down FoS and HoS's. But I'm not one to keep my vote somewhere that it's not doing anything.