yes... and it seems you're not mafia as i'd be hammered.

Correct me if I'm wrong but if theres 4 town and 2 scum left, with townies out the door tomorrow, doesn't the town lose regardless of whether or not we lynch correctly? 2-1 town vs scum tomorrow. 

Look

Scar-Hobo

Gluttony-Janitor

Lust-Witch

Armstrong-Friendly neighbor

Aplhonse and Edward-Siblings

Mustang-Arsonist

Greed-Bulletproof

Using my knowledge of FMA, I'd belive Hughes is Actor

The roles are fitting but uncoomon, and bus driver would not fit if that's what stefl claimed for Hughes.

Never mind I'm stupid

He could still be Maes but lying about his role

thank you ^^

That's a possibility taking into account the fact that people lose roles when claiming, and should only do so when facing the direst of circumstances.

I know it doesn't, fit that was one of my problems from the get go... or to say it better, when the first roles where revealed...

First off, we don't know that there is 2 mafia left.  Second off, no.  If we lynch scum today, I will die tonight, and you will die tonight.  So we would be down to 2 town and 1 scum.  Assuming the mafia doesn't have another day kill, the townies could then lynch the other scum.

It sounded like a good idea at first, but the more I think about it, it really doesn't make any sense whatsoever that there are 2 scum left.  The town would have to be near perfect throughout the whole entire game for a chance of winning.

Stefl who did you swap night 2 and 3?