Hephaestos said:
in short.
1) yeah FF is SK and visited prof.... BUT!.... deducing he was the SK is straightforward, of the 2 persons thinking ball was claiming psych, i was the only one to tell him I was not his target. Then deducing he visited proff... well duh!
2) Now regarding Link's claim.... ABC doesn't know who visited him, no one came forward.... bu who did vetteman visit? Does the hobo role also make the neighboor visit fail? No one came forward with the info of Vetteman's visit, why? Only logical conclusion is that he visited ABC and since he's a Hobo, didn't find him to deliver his message.
3) Put A and B together, you have a nicely crafted watcher/tracker claim with 2 night's worth of information that was just barely on our finger tips already. A gamble with weighted risk.
4) Also linkz says coping him is not necessary, coping notstan instead will do the trick... yes the usual scum trick, send one of your mates to the gullag and then go to victory. (wasn't there the mention of a godfather with the presence fo a miller?)
in any case, Linkz is not top of my list.
|
1) Only 2 people spoke up about thinking Baal being pyschiatrist. It will later be revealed I had the same thoughts, before I mentioned them day three, and I would wager that prof was only acting dumb about it. TOS also claimed today he thought Baal meant psych. Remember the first post of the day that you thought was a scum tell. That was actually a subtle claim that I knew without a doubt who killed him and was also a secret message.
Baal not being poisoned paints a giant question mark over his head, though like I said earlier I'm willing to go one more night and he WILL claim tomorrow. He's the reason I bring up the possibility of a godfather, especially given the other investigative roles.
2) Do you really think Vette would deliver a message of his towniness to ABC? It's also possible that Vette chose not to deliver a message, or that the message went to scum and they didn't want to claim it.
Once again(or rather prior to the other one) I was trying to send a secret message with my first post of the day, although it was misinterpreted as I never accounted for the possibility of an untargetable type role.(Nor a roleblock as I originally though hat was taunting me with since I got no message at all) Seriously, read the begining of day two again and tell me I faked that.
3) What's the reward though? Fakeclaiming Watcher as scum at the risk of a real Watcher existing would get me lynched very quickly. And if I'm scum I'm not going to die at night after FF dies, so starting night 4 I'd be expected to have information again. You can say the cursed claim counters that, but it's only 50% and with nobody else claiming to be cursed that would be a huge waste at countering town powers.
4) I'm saying that because I am able to see merge the information that the cop knows with the information I know. If you like, I'll give myself a big mouth and out him. I have no idea what alignment NotStan(though to be clear I believe he should be burned now and not scanned) is, but I do know several targets that it'd be a waste on. Futhermore, I suggested the cop should scan Stefl now, who would ideally target me. The cop can confirm Stefl who will be able to confirm quite a bit, and if the three of us are all still alive I'll even explain a portion of his results.
