By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - VGC Mafia Round -28- FullMetal Alchemist

Linkzmax said:

Okay, let's try this. I can confirm ABC's story day two, because I tried to Watch him. I got no result back.(Hobo claim fits since he has no home to be targeted at)

Last night I targeted prof, and take a guess who visited him?

FF?

If that, there is no guarantee that you're pro town nor does it necessarily meant that you have the ability to watch, for example a watcher last game said that he saw the person at a crime scene but it turned out that the watcher had a 3rd party agenda in mind, so I wouldn't rule out that you're trying to bullshit here either, whether you're third party or a mafia trying to frame someone and clear ABC at the same time is a possibility.

Voting for Final-Fan may be a waste of a lynch for us at the moment, as it stands he's going to die tonight anyway, and with the kill he may even go for a mafia member taking into account that they're the ones responsible for his upcoming death - that is if he is SK. At least we can agree on one thing, ToS is acting mighty inconspicious this round, usually he's a valuable asset to town.



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

Around the Network
Baalzamon said:

You know, I really think leatherhat's supposed confusion towards whether or not prof was mafia has just seemed strange.  Even after the OP stated specifically that he was mafia, he came out with another statement saying he believes prof is mafia.

Vote: Leatherhat

Also, to Linkz.  I don't think it is far too much of a leap.  FF thought I was a psychiatrist.  Yesterday, in one of his posts, he said something along the lines of if I don't shut up, he will just reveal it for me.  He then went on to wink at me.  This may mean absolutely nothing, but knowing now what he thought of me, I think he wanted me to know who he was.  After all, why would it hurt him if a psychiatrist would convert him over to the town.  Matter of fact, his odds of winning the game would probably be greatly increased.  Now today, he is in a situation where he will die after tonight (unless there is some sort of poison doctor).  Rather than roleclaiming in order to help the town, he says that he will refrain from roleclaiming because it is the best for the town.  Unless he is an SK, why would there be any reason that a role claim wouldn't be better for the town?


I actually just didn't read the OP, but I guess I can understand why you wouldn't believe that.

FF seems like a waste of a vote even if they are scum so my vote as to which scum we are going to target is still up in the air. 



ǝןdɯıs ʇı dǝǝʞ oʇ ǝʞıן ı ʍouʞ noʎ 

Ask me about being an elitist jerk

Time for hype

In terms of activity leatherhat seems to have enough time to post elsewhere but no time to check in on the mafia thread, likely reading but not contributing so a lurker, and a suspicious one to me. ToS shows activity but doesn't post elsewhere - I am not sure if even posts anywhere outside of mafia threads - again most likely lurking or just doesn't have enough time to post in general.

I still think that my vote is wellfounded and will likely pressure leatherhat into taking part in the game and contributing in a positive way.



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

NotStan said:
Linkzmax said:

Okay, let's try this. I can confirm ABC's story day two, because I tried to Watch him. I got no result back.(Hobo claim fits since he has no home to be targeted at)

Last night I targeted prof, and take a guess who visited him?

FF?

If that, there is no guarantee that you're pro town nor does it necessarily meant that you have the ability to watch, for example a watcher last game said that he saw the person at a crime scene but it turned out that the watcher had a 3rd party agenda in mind, so I wouldn't rule out that you're trying to bullshit here either, whether you're third party or a mafia trying to frame someone and clear ABC at the same time is a possibility.

Voting for Final-Fan may be a waste of a lynch for us at the moment, as it stands he's going to die tonight anyway, and with the kill he may even go for a mafia member taking into account that they're the ones responsible for his upcoming death - that is if he is SK. At least we can agree on one thing, ToS is acting mighty inconspicious this round, usually he's a valuable asset to town.

If I'm scum then it's a one-for-one trade with someone that's going to die anyway. Think before you speak. Additionally, I'd be damning ABC along with myself if that were the case. I'm confirming ABC's story. He could be scum, but I lean town.

I want a claim from FF. He may be the best lynch even if he's dying tonight, because while he may hit mafia again, odds say he'll hit town. With no chance of winning as SK there's no incentive to help either side.



Ninja'd by Leatherhat it seems, he decided to finally post same minute as I was typing mine up



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

Around the Network

I sincerely wish I could know for sure whether or not Linkz is telling the truth about FF.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

Baalzamon said:

I sincerely wish I could know for sure whether or not Linkz is telling the truth about FF.

Help me get him to claim. It'll likely come down to my word against his, but I'm still holding a few trumps.



Linkzmax said:
NotStan said:
Linkzmax said:

Okay, let's try this. I can confirm ABC's story day two, because I tried to Watch him. I got no result back.(Hobo claim fits since he has no home to be targeted at)

Last night I targeted prof, and take a guess who visited him?

FF?

If that, there is no guarantee that you're pro town nor does it necessarily meant that you have the ability to watch, for example a watcher last game said that he saw the person at a crime scene but it turned out that the watcher had a 3rd party agenda in mind, so I wouldn't rule out that you're trying to bullshit here either, whether you're third party or a mafia trying to frame someone and clear ABC at the same time is a possibility.

Voting for Final-Fan may be a waste of a lynch for us at the moment, as it stands he's going to die tonight anyway, and with the kill he may even go for a mafia member taking into account that they're the ones responsible for his upcoming death - that is if he is SK. At least we can agree on one thing, ToS is acting mighty inconspicious this round, usually he's a valuable asset to town.

If I'm scum then it's a one-for-one trade with someone that's going to die anyway. Think before you speak. Additionally, I'd be damning ABC along with myself if that were the case. I'm confirming ABC's story. He could be scum, but I lean town.

I want a claim from FF. He may be the best lynch even if he's dying tonight, because while he may hit mafia again, odds say he'll hit town. With no chance of winning as SK there's no incentive to help either side.

Yeah but what I meant was, what guarantee is that you're pro town and that you're a watcher? You practically role claimed there so your ability will likely be blocked for the night - unless of course you role claimed falsely. What I meant was, ABC was the main suspect the other day until he roleclaimed - which could still be doubted, however you mentioning him in the way that you did effectively clears both you and him.



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

Linkzmax said:
Baalzamon said:

I sincerely wish I could know for sure whether or not Linkz is telling the truth about FF.

Help me get him to claim. It'll likely come down to my word against his, but I'm still holding a few trumps.

The more I think about it, the less I feel it is a good idea for him to claim.  I sincerely believe the town will be better off if we attempt to take out a mafia member instead of him for the lynch today.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

NotStan said:

Yeah but what I meant was, what guarantee is that you're pro town and that you're a watcher? You practically role claimed there so your ability will likely be blocked for the night - unless of course you role claimed falsely. What I meant was, ABC was the main suspect the other day until he roleclaimed - which could still be doubted, however you mentioning him in the way that you did effectively clears both you and him.

The only reason the Watcher last round was anti-town is because he was converted. Watcher would be an extremely weak scum role, and would be nearly impossible to fake as any alignment.

I decided to claim, because like Heph I was cursed last night so my chances of success tonight were reduced already.

That was exactly my intention both day two and with my reveal today. Even though I won't have a scan tonight, I've given myself a bullseye. It's important that townies know someone else shouldn't be lynched on any future days.