Luigi because Mario gets all the attention.

exactly the character i was thinking about as soon as i read the title.

he's just so likeable =(

strahl (Killzone 3)
*spoilers*
yeah sure he was going to kill everyone on earth with his super weapon 

what I am saying is if it was anyone else they would have been unable to get them engines online and if orlock had just paid attention to the convoy on the right (like strahl had advised) sev and rico would have had to deal with a lot more when trying to leave helghan.

if he had been in charge after visari died and thankfully he wasn't the isa troops on helghan would have been dealt with alot quicker and earth would have been in serious trouble.

so I am glad he didn't get his own way but Gureilla tried to make you sympathetic to him and it sort of worked.

Scott Shelby from Heavy Rain.

EDIT: Can't get the spoiler tag to work properly.  You know why I feel bad for him if you beat the game.

On topic:

The Colossi in SotC. Particularly Phalanx. It's not even trying to attack you, for Christ's sakes!

The criminals in Metro City. (Or ANYBODY, who gets in the way of Mike flipping Haggar.)

Fawful, at the end of BIS. He just wanted some kingdom conquering...

Anybody, who's played 3D Ballz.

Scott Shelby from Heavy Rain

*spoilers*

"It wasn't bravery, it was love. I held John's hand while he was drowning."

" I've been waiting for so long for a father capable of giving his life for his son, and what do I get?! Nothing! Nobody!

What's real love if it isn't sacrifice?!

All these people saying they love each other - they're just a pack of liars!!! You shouldn't have got mixed up in this. You discovered my little secret and it will die with you... "

May I help you remember that he does both Elena and Cloe?

Or maybe the other way around, for the same reason.

PS and on topic: I cried both when John Marston rode to his wife (compass was the perfect song for those tears, you know) and after when they were buring him.

Schala from Chrono Trigger.

So, she just can't die like her lucky mother, can she? She has to be absorved by Lavos and have an eternal endless suffering.

Layton from Layton 3.

So he finally meets with the love of his life, only for her to die minutes afterwards.

otacon...need i say more

Good point, my sympathy is gone.