At this point, I think there's too many people saying alignments don't match to go along with your theory. That being said, I wouldn't mind lynching Darth for his lurker status and the arkwark timing of his roleclaim. He could have very well made it because he figured we'd think a Mafia wouldn't dare make such a claim.

To be blunt, I think the people claiming otherwise are lying. As a rule I don't trust a thing anyone says in these games. We have 5 bits of data for, and potentially 2 against with a third on debate publicly. I am not so annoying as to accuse everyone against me of being scum so I am choosing to let it play out. If I survive long enough we have a pretty good kill list that I am comfortable seeing where it goes.

@A Bad Clown
I have less interest in the deaths of those lurkers as a whole. Yes more bits of data would help, and another night of lynchings/killings will bust or prove my theory certainly but I choose to focus on the ones most likely to help me win. It is a secondary concern for me, but still a concern.

Actually, some parts of gnizmo's thoery make sense. He says the lich king used to be go but turned evil later, and isn't there a mafia role for someone who can be recruited into the mafia? Like if one night the mafia targets someone they have the option of recruiting him? I read this on the mafia wiki

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Traitor

I believe that would make sense with the lich king thing

Can I assume this means yours does not match? I won't ask for anymore character reveals as it spoils the mystery, but I would like bits of data. Not so many have come against that they couldn't all be scum, but the game will be really fucking boring if so cause they would all of them certainly. wowwiki.com should give you the answers. All of my work has been from memory so you might be able to spot things I missed, or have progressed since I last played a Warcraft game.

Right now, I'd be willing to lynch either darth or notstan. 

And both because of things notstan has said. I specifically do not like notstan's FoS on vette.

@gniz

I'm kil'jaeden

I'm not quite certain yet, I still think there is some sort of relation between the names, but it might not be quite so obvious as good in warcraft = good in vgchartz mafia and bad in mafia = bad in vgchartz mafia

Well you have been against the theory up until like right now. Are you suddenly a convert? It certainly would make my case stronger.

bad in warcraft = bad in vgchartz mafia***

Quoting this to put the radish quote into context.

He did say

the "siblings"

meaning if he was aware of it, he definitely didn't know who the townie one was.... on the other hand that would confirm Dsister as the other sibling as the info refered to is ABC saying he had something on Dsister...I don't see any other way for this sibling slip to be true. (otherwise it'd be just as I thought yesterday, confused radish). (and I can't believe proff missed the siblings text when I called radish on it...that's like 5 posts on the subject)

-> proving the siblings theory would be easy by killing Dsister (though the townie sibling would die) as if there is an evil one revealed by Radish, all points to him.

On the other hand, do we really need to?

With a second night kill, they are the most likely to die at night, and now with me saying this, an SK/vig/mafiaB could hit 2 birds with one stone there... and the town save a lynch...

(yeah i'm a bastard to bring this up in the open as this very likely will get dsister killed at night.... but he's on my radar and I believe the theory sound, worst case town loses a townie at night... which is expected... so it's really win win for all parties (besides mafia A)).

I counted you amongst the skeptics I believe. I kept you in mind for certain still. You could be scum for all I know. With A Bad Clown's thought it would have 3 Burning Legion members and a Traitor matching up quite nicely. It sure as hell fits the lore for Arthas to be a traitor as well. Medivh as a watcher is a touch of a stretch, and mine certainly doesn't match though so its hard to get definitive there. As I said though I am not going to pursue this further during this day, and I honestly don't think much more good can come of discussing it unless people en masse start commenting on the match-ups.