good point with A-B...though the same color death for less info could coincide with no AB for less info.

AND now that the cat is out of the bag.... Wonk what do you have to say for your defence?

Kel Thuzad? The evil Lich who was raised in order to cause massive death and destruction? The thing responsible for the destruction of multiple cities, and countless lives while living and dead? In a game that has name linked to faction? Ueah, I am going to believe this. My name and alignment match just like the two dead people. Their roles even match up with what they should be (which really leaves me annoyed on my character/role match-up but that is a rant for when I role claim).

Here is where it could get funky. This is obviously not a vanilla game, and you are undead. Healing would, naturally, kill you. There is a very tiny risk the doctor would randomly save you if you are a townie and thus no reason to even attempt to avert it. Yet here you are trying it. All of that mashes up into a not very nice picture of you. So unless a few other people can come out and say their role and faction don't match up I am going to just stick by a vote for you. 3 is a pattern as they say, and the pattern says you are scum.

Vote: darthdevidm

Final-fan's death is quite simple to explain. He has a tendency to win when he survives. At least at last I saw. Hell I know whenever I was scum he was automagically on the top of my hit list. Before anyone jumps on that I assure you he wouldn't be on the top of my list this game. I can think of at least one person who would go first regardless.

I was gonna look more into ff post but I wanted to do mafia first, then it being 1 in the moning I got tired and went to sleep.

This, is oddly convincing, though I have to bring up the fact that we are cosplayers, not actually our characters.

Maybe it means he is allergic to penicillin or something? I have no idea. But I do know that he cannot be a townie AND killed by doctor, because he said he was against lying as a townie, adn this would be an obvious half-truth.

I have to say I find it very interesting that Darth would come out and claim. There must be some reason for it because otherwise it just looks like a dumb move that gives the mafia too much information. Your analysis seems to be the best solution, yet...

appreciated. I think both are interesting.

Thank you for this precision.

Now, the Mafia A and B theory seems a bit more possible.

About #2, I'm not liking it very much. One of the strengths of the Mafia is that they benefit from many points of view to make their decision and guide their actions. Apart from the obvious benefits of having a Mafia dead, another reward for the town was that the Mafia had one less mind to plan their evil schemes.

1) ok

2) umh... i guess it's ok as radish has never so far come up with a master plan to rule the world, but if it were a dead Hatmoza or Proff, i'd be weary of that new rule... they could pupeteer the whole mafia team ^^

editted text back into this ghost post;

I believe radish slipped when he mentioned THE sibling. Every time he mentioned A sibling, he said THE sibling.

"Are you THE sibling"- "I'm not THE other sibling"

I'm surprised I missed this. In the off chance that there actually IS a sibling in the mafia, I first of all doubt that the townie version would know his sibling, but that the mafia would know the townie. So, I am going to go back and look at people radish defended, as well as other players that were defended. (But mainly radish in particular since I know he's mafia)

And yes, this does imply that I'm willing to lynch a sibling townie.