I liked that dsister's actively trying to get the game going with these questions. My gut tells me to attack those who give the wrong or suspicious answers but my experience tells me it's a bit too early to attack players for them already.

To answer the post btw:

1-  I always was pro lynching lurkers. However, my stubborn mind has come to the conclusion that lurkers can just as easily be pro-town players opposed to the scum I always leaned towards them being. So I don't think I'll push for first day 1 lynches like I used to. Nonetheless, the idea of scum striking first blood always boils my own.

2- Lynch all liars. So for fuck sake people. If you don't have a good ... GOOD reason for lying as pro-town, don't lie at all. Little white lies that you can prove were false for whatever reason can sometimes be negligible. However scum will use that to their advantage, that is why you're still at risk of getting lynch.

3- I already mentioned lurkers but ... I just hope they're never pro-town. I've witnessed too many townies fall by the "lurking card" that it has left me quite paranoid.

@Final-fan
In his defense there are times to lie. He just chose a shitty example. If someone asks if you are a cop/doctor the answer is always no. As such lying is easily defnsible in extreme circumstances.

@prof
The situations are different. I typed it up twice and had it eatten by my internet. I will elaborate more later, but it revolves around him defending both.

But maybe he is certain, if he is in fact a sibling, whether he admits to it or not.

I agree with prof, I initially thought good of dsister's discussion post until he prematurely attacked heph.

I will lynch them without thought or remorse. It can hang the game at night because the person was too lazy to read a paragraph of text. I can think of absolutely no reason to avoid reading it. No scenario can ever be conceived where that is reasonable.

Not to mention that those three question are all day 1 discussion topics from previous games...

Wasn't it Trucks who brought up the discussion of townies lying in a previous game? And how many times are we to discuss day 1 lynches or lurkers on the first day?

The more I think about dsister's post the more irked I become.

dsister does this every game though. Maybe not the exact same questions, but the method of fostering discussion. Lynch all liars is also an extremely common ideology. I really think you are both reading way too much into this.

Anyways I'm going to do my first FoS to dsister right now, he'd better have a good reason for what he's been doing...

Yes truck brought that up in the sailor moon game

and he was Mafia!!

Since I haven't played with everyone here, or the rest of you guys for awhile I decided to throw it in for a refresher, as well as to liven up the conversation 

And as I said in a previous post the first question is important because it would show me if I could avoid the same old tired arguement of whether or not we need a day 1 lynch.

And what do you mean I was looking for support in voting Heph? You mean to give a reason? Yeah, people seem to not like it when I vote randomly on this site, or do you mean I was looking for other people to vote him too? If so, that makes no sense as I didn't know he lies nor did I ask those questions just to give me a reason to vote him. I had no intention of voting for him till after he admitted he is fine with lying to the town 

Strange, but ok O.o 

The last few times that I remember playing here I could sware I remember 20%, but as Trucks can tell you I have a horrible memory

I don't make the rules. I just play the game... And the 20% is the one I have played with the most, be it here, or mafiascum(<-Especially mafiascum)

You also fail to factor in third parties. A serial killer would make the game much shorter 

And discussion is a bad thing? I don't see how lying can be a good thing at all. It just gets in the way. Yes,  you might get lucky and no one might notice it, but if someone does you create a lot of confusion and wasted effort that can be used to hunt scum. 

I've played here before, and I know what happens if I vote for someone with no reason. It doesn't end well. So yes, I did give some reason for my vote. If someone else comes up that needs pressure or someone that I genuinly believe is scum appears then I will change my vote to them.

Also discussion is the single most important part to scum hunting. For some reason not all scum are like Mario and tell you in their first post of the game(-_-).

What's stopping you? Throw that vote down on me