prof much of your arguments are dependent on MG being scum and prof being a player that would "parent" an entire mafia team.

Also did you not read the list I made just for you? Trucks is one of two people I would work against lynching today. You should have stuck with metal gear.

Why?  What has he done to deserve such an honor?

has the good cop approach that isn't insulting

asks questions answers questions

waited on hammering notstan

most players trust him

he seems more valuable alive than dead

plus to cover my bases if he is scum and buddying it might keep me save a little longer

oh yeah wanted to ask about that back then...

what's an accidental post?

I suspect this had to do with the Hat threat. I don't see why you'd die tonight though.

congratz that's your most towny post of the game.

and I did read your description, it wasn't that vague, though it did narrow you down to 2 roles. One of why is unlikely.

1) hat was a bodyguard, his opinion on the game is as good as any townie's, which means it's not proof of anything.

2) Who defended you? Well proff asked for unvotes to keep the discution, but didn't do a straight up defence. If he's your scum buddy, he did a smart move, as unvotes create momentum and can by itself save someone. If he's just buddying to you, it's also smart as it doesn't implicate him much and can generate a townie feel  (look at how wonk trust trucks for waiting on the notstan hammer... little things can generate trust).

I read the arguments as Trucks pushing for MG's lynch without commiting himself, not as MG being his scum buddy.... That is the part of the argumentation that I find convincing.

I'm in line with you on the parenting though, when ABC pops up scum, there's a real parenting case on Proff for that... but on trucks... i'm not convinced.

you've been waiting for posts a lot to make your descisions ^^

Do you have any input on the Truck Proff MG ABC cases?

wonk you are getting carried away.

My evidence on trucks has absolutely nothing to do with mg.

I've been saying for days on and on THAT I THINK MG IS THE SK.

THE S-K. 

I said this already because in a two killer game, mafia are also scumhunting because they want to provide us with a scum so that they are both safer, and look better to townies. So, the target that mafia should collectively find to be the most suspicious could have a high chance of being the SK, right?

That's all I've ever been saying about that, and I don't know how it's ever gotten twisted to the point where my whole case rests on Trucks parenting MG. That's an insane amount of spin, and I'm not sure who's the guilty party there.

@Heph, an accidental post was when I logged into vg from a bookmark, and accidentally posted in mafia 25 instead of this one.

That's a more valid point than anything prof has presented so far.

MetalGear falls into the same category as Darth, suspicious mostly because of lurking. I believe in lynching lurkers but It's hard to put out solid case against someone who doesn't post. For darth, his roleclaim out of the blue convinced me he was scum. For MetalGear, it's his quick vote on Day One that supports my suspicions on him but other than that I can't commit myself much further because there's nothing to analyze.