Uncharted 3 - 94

Gears of war 3 - 92

"in game footage would be better"

WTF!?  That trailer footage from the OP wasn't from the game, either.  None of the Gears of War trailers are ever from the actual game!  There's much better screens of GeoW3 than even the one that was linked to but you insist on having a pic with a girl in it.  It's okay.  It's your thread.  It's just strange that one bullshot is picked over another bullshot as credible.

*edit* looks like somebody posted some decent screens.  I still haven't voted yet.

i meant gameplay, i dont want a cgi pic CGI.

yeah, i know my  gears picture isnt gameplay either, if acknowleged that already but it definitely not concept art

Uncharted 3 below 90, because with what happened to KZ3/GT5 this fucked up gaming journalism will do it. <90 quote me on that.

My guess is that critics will mark both games down via nitpick(ala KZ3/LBP2/Halo reach) even tho they say its much better than the previous one.

heck Im even scared for both might drop below 90 in meta, hey its possible.

how is that not gameplay, in the actual video of where i got my uncharted picture, was from someone playing the game.

you can see the HUD. its not a bull shot

BTW why are you guys arguing about a mere PIC?

the uncharted 3 screen shot isnt that great either to begin with I dont see complaints tho.....

You misunderstood me.  I'm saying that that pic from the OP of the lady holding a rifle isn't from the real game.  It's from the trailer.  Gears trailers never show what really happens in game.  I didn't comment about the Uncharted pic at all except for earlier when I said that Gears looked like shit by comparison.

whats my agenda?

two different games...