By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Mubarack steps down.

Kasz216 said:
elticker said:
Kasz216 said:
elticker said:
elticker said:
Slimebeast said:
elticker said:
Joelcool7 said:
elticker said:
Joelcool7 said:

I hope the military does a good job of ensuring democracy and human rights. I'm not sure what is in the Egyptian Constitution but freedom of religion, speech etc...etc... need to be ensured in a future Egypt. The Military should also ensure that no radical extremist groups are allowed to participate in the election. Also the military should do everything in its power to keep Egypt on a moderate path.

If Muslim Brotherhood get in during elections lets hope they don't try to radicalize the country. Also the Egyptian Christian's have faced persecution for years I hope that the military and Government (Who ever elected) take steps to protect minorities.

In the end I hope the new Government isn't radical, a true human rights loving democratic party would do wonders for Egypt. Imagine a middle eastern country with all the freedoms and democracy of a western nation, that would be amazing and thats what I hope happens. But theirs a chance tyrants will get in control, start a war thousands if not millions will die, that would not be good at all.


are you talking about the same brotherhood i think i know since they were walking with women and christains in the streets they prayed in their own way without the brotherhood interruption and they didn't tell women to cover their heads. you know what a democracy is right so if people want hte brotherhood to rule egypt then it should as people make decision and reap the benefits or the consequences. egyptains should decide their future.

Yep I'm talking about the same Brotherhood. While they appear more moderate now they used to have an armed wing which we would call terrorists. From what I've heard reported the BrotherHood is pro-strict sharia law and also a supporter of Hamas and Hezbullah.

Also yes your right in a democracy the Egyptians will choose the Government. I just hope that some political parties are formed that will ensure Egypt remains on the path of human rights and peace. A government that supports Hamas and Hezbullah would be very bad for Egypt and peace in the middle east.

As Mr.Bubbles said the west is alittle concerned if an extremist group or supporter of extremist groups got in control it could lead to a new huge war in the middle east. We all know that any huge war in the middle east will only bring repression , pain and suffering and hatred. Thousands to millions could die and even more would be displaced.

Plus we all know Israel would kick Egypt, Lebanon and Hamas's butts if another huge war occured. If they ever looked like they were loosing the west would come in and rescue them. Either way it would be a disaster for Egyptian's Palestinian's , Lebanese and Israeli's.

Nobody would make any gains in a war and who ever wins the war would still have lost far more then they could possibly gain.

we will see about that as i am sure there will be a war between israel and egypt but i don't forsee it until atleast 20 to 30 years when egypt has established itself. I am an egyptain and currently i don't want war with israel but in the future when we get pwoerful enough i want us to help palestine by stopping all the land israel is getting by stealing it from the original owners and keep peace between them, but if another war is to happen i hope israel doesn't resort to nuclear weapons threat so that the usa could support them like they did in 1973. Also take in mind that the yum kippur war was only syria and egypt, saudi arabia, jordan, all the oil countries didn't participate until the war was almost over.

 also if they listened to saad elshazly we would have tactically won as they disobeyed him and thats why the israeli counterattack was so successful. i have to admit that the israeli commando performance was great which in part led to the disruption of our communication which was also a major factor in the breakdown of our defenses. also many claim that the 1973 war convinced arabs that israel is undefeatable buti believe and so many egyptains that we can beat israel if we go to another war, however i don't want to go to war as egyptains will be killed in the war.

the israeli airforce was superior to the egyptain air force.

The Jews came there first, long before Arabs. In my personal opinion Arabs don't even really belong in Egypt. Arabs conquered Egypt, made the population Islamic and forced the Christians to submit and become a silent minority and I don't think that's a good thing.

It's saddening to hear you as an Egyptian are talking about a future war with Israel only because you are so upset about the Palestinian situation. Only because they're your Arab brothers.

No wonder Israel sees the whole Arab/muslim world as a threat.

arabs didn't force christains to convert btw. you just had to pay a 2.5% of your income fee which is so much more cheaper than taxes besides muslims are also supposed ot pay that. Besides i find war with israel a must in the future if we were to support palestinaines in which israel evicts the original residents to put their own. If they stop stuff like that it becomes so much easier for me to imagine peace with israel.


also they support our dictators to keep us opressed which is more than enough of a reason to go to war. A war for freedom as they were the ones supporting mubarak all these years along with the USA. USA hypocracy about democracy is so obvious. its a democracy only if it suits the USA. you know the USA interveining in our internal affairs is what actaully makes us not like the USA. Most don't hate the USA but dislike how it intervienes in every affair, it sucks when our country has to be opressed for 30 years by the USA and have no dignity, being humilated in almost all arab countries because we kept getting poorer once that dictator mubarak became president. You know I actually felt proud by what we did so proud and happy, that i actually realised that the USA is what kept us so humiliated. you don;t know how it feels. i am going to canada for university, i wish i could go to egypt for uni but hte universities in egypt suck right now cause of how bad the ministry of education is, the ministary of education was chosen by mubarak has he did fixed elections.

You do know that the US is basically why Mubarack stepped down right?  Had their not of been urgings from the US... he would of got much more violent.

Your general black and white thinking is quite disturbing and the same side coin of the things you claim to hate.

I mean, look how unhappy people were at the US in the last two attempts they've made to institute democracies.

In general, the USA can't win...and by default gets blamed for things soley because it's the biggest guy in the room, and it's easier to blame the biggest guy in the room then it is to deal with the reality of the situation and why things are the way they were.


The US was very quick to support a revolution when one was viable, the behind the scenes work it did preventing things from getting out of hand was very intergral.  To blame them for working with the people in charge when there was no viable alternative is just a wrong conception.  Afterall, as has been shown, the world doesn't like it when the US fights peoples revolutions for them.


oh yah did you see the video of the car of the US embassy running down protesters,

Yes.  Did you happen to know that car was stolen from the embassy along with a few others?

I don't see the point though, other then you've conceded my points and are trying to divert attention away with a story you only half know.

actaully it isn't a diversion i forgut what i wanted ot say about that topic. besides during the revolution mubarak resisted US pressure, if he didn't he would have made omar solieman president for the transitional period instead of the army. You might not like it but generally the egyptain army was ordered by mubarak regime to opress protesters but it refused. Also police used live ammunition so you saying that the usa stopped that, please enlighten me how the USA stopped the police from being brutal when the police was very brutal arresting alot tortuing using live munition tear gas is that what the USA stopped the police doing 



 

 

Around the Network
Slimebeast said:
elticker said:
Slimebeast said:
elticker said:
Slimebeast said:

The Jews came there first, long before Arabs. In my personal opinion Arabs don't even really belong in Egypt. Arabs conquered Egypt, made the population Islamic and forced the Christians to submit and become a silent minority and I don't think that's a good thing.

It's saddening to hear you as an Egyptian are talking about a future war with Israel only because you are so upset about the Palestinian situation. Only because they're your Arab brothers.

No wonder Israel sees the whole Arab/muslim world as a threat.

arabs didn't force christains to convert btw. you just had to pay a 2.5% of your income fee which is so much more cheaper than taxes besides muslims are also supposed ot pay that. Besides i find war with israel a must in the future if we were to support palestinaines in which israel evicts the original residents to put their own. If they stop stuff like that it becomes so much easier for me to imagine peace with israel.

They're not original residents just as Arabs are not original residents of Egypt.

correct me if am wrong but the red indains are the original residents os why did you kill them and take over their lands since you aren't even an original residents. so if an indain american came he could go to your home and take over it because they were the original residents?

I'm not an American but yes, going by your argumentation Indians have more right to the soil of USA than the Palestinian Arabs have to the land of Israel.


It's true.  It'd make a lot more sense if the Native Americans went all terrorrist on the USA.   Hell, there aren't even any Native American countries to move to, in a sad way America is the best they've got.  The fact there isn't native american terrorist groups is shocking.  (Or if there are, i haven't heard of them.)

Now if I was a Palestinian.  I'd try and immigrate to any country that would have me.  It's not like the land they're fighting for is worth much anyway... pointless.  They should have the common sense to sign whatever deal they can, build up their strength and then argue they deserve more and signed under coeercement.  Instead they let their leaders force them to suffer and use them for martyrs in hopes that in decades in the future they'll get 1-2% more land.



elticker said:
Kasz216 said:
 

Yes.  Did you happen to know that car was stolen from the embassy along with a few others?

I don't see the point though, other then you've conceded my points and are trying to divert attention away with a story you only half know.

actaully it isn't a diversion i forgut what i wanted ot say about that topic. besides during the revolution mubarak resisted US pressure, if he didn't he would have made omar solieman president for the transitional period instead of the army. You might not like it but generally the egyptain army was ordered by mubarak regime to opress protesters but it refused. Also police used live ammunition so you saying that the usa stopped that, please enlighten me how the USA stopped the police from being brutal when the police was very brutal arresting alot tortuing using live munition tear gas is that what the USA stopped the police doing 

If they would of went any stronger, they would of faced heavy problems from the US.  As for the military refusing... I mean, your from Egypt. 

You should know better then anybody that the military is like... 500,000 people strong.  The various paramilitary, police and intellegence agencies greatly outnumber it.

He didn't need the military.

This does illustrate though why everybody from conservatives to liberals were upset with how reserved Obama was early, even when he had behind the scenes been pushing for him to step down shortly after the protests started.



Also... I would feel a LOT better about this transfer if the Egyptian military weren't trying to remove the protestors from Tahir square.

There should be no problem in letting them stay their if they plan to honor their word.



Kasz216 said:
Slimebeast said:

I'm not an American but yes, going by your argumentation Indians have more right to the soil of USA than the Palestinian Arabs have to the land of Israel.


It's true.  It'd make a lot more sense if the Native Americans went all terrorrist on the USA.   Hell, there aren't even any Native American countries to move to, in a sad way America is the best they've got.  The fact there isn't native american terrorist groups is shocking.  (Or if there are, i haven't heard of them.)

Now if I was a Palestinian.  I'd try and immigrate to any country that would have me.  It's not like the land they're fighting for is worth much anyway... pointless.  They should have the common sense to sign whatever deal they can, build up their strength and then argue they deserve more and signed under coeercement.  Instead they let their leaders force them to suffer and use them for martyrs in hopes that in decades in the future they'll get 1-2% more land.

Thats the way I see it. The Jews did that for ~2000 years. Worked out pretty darn well for them. If I were the Palestiniean government, I would make peace with Israel, never attack them, work with all other countries in the region, and wait for Israel to slip up. If they slip up, then its proven they are the instigators. If not, then I enjoy peace and prosperity.

To me, what the Palestinieans are doing would be like Mexico deciding to attack America for its lost territories in former wars. Peace is a much more attractive option, IMO.



Back from the dead, I'm afraid.

Around the Network

Unfortunately, despite the rationality of peace - The Palestinieans and the Jews will find excuse to attack each other (All people, regardless of decent contain hardliners). Heck, even if religion or history weren't plausible enough, someone will make up another.

As to Eygpt's change of government, it's hopeful there won't be another un-democratic state, but it's a plausible and real fear there won't. Granted, I think that the real wish of any western government will be that no one will remember who helped keep Mubarak there.

Granted, it's rather amusing the focus of the media is on Eygpt despite everything tacking place in the rest of the middle east. Large amounts of the region are facing an uprise, hopefully a successful one.



The true test of any scholar's work is not what his contemporaries say, but what happens to his work in the next 25 or 50 years. - Milton Friedman.

Xen said:
Don86 said:

Israel is probably aiming their nukes and missiles at egypt just to be safe LOL

I guess. We did move two divisions south though!


You're a jew?



elticker said:


oh yah did you see the video of the car of the US embassy running down protesters,

As Kaz said it was stolen. But even if it wasn't did you see the video's of Egyptian protestors attacking pretty much anyone foreign? CTV, CBC, Fox, CNN all were reporting that their journalists were being attacked by Egyptian protestors. A group of Canadian journalists were pulled from their cars and the translator said the egyptians planned on killing them, luckily the army intervened and rescued them.

Canada, the US and other countries only supported the Egyptian Government all these years because they were the Government. You say Egyptian's don't like the US playing around with your countries affairs, as such what did you expect them to do? Come into Egypt topple the Government and insert democracy? Wouldn't that have been meddaling in your affairs? Or should the US have boycott your Government and sanctioned the shit out of it?

The US Canada and other governments respected Egypts soveirnty and did not meddle in your countries affairs anymore then any other country. Sure they signed peace agreements and trade but they always respected your countries independance.

Egyptians would be just as mad if America meddled and intervened militarily to instal democracy. The US and Canada helped get Mubarak to step down. They have done everything they could for the egyptian people.

 

P.S- which University in Canada you going too?



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer

 

Sheeplord said:

Unfortunately, despite the rationality of peace - The Palestinieans and the Jews will find excuse to attack each other (All people, regardless of decent contain hardliners). Heck, even if religion or history weren't plausible enough, someone will make up another.

As to Eygpt's change of government, it's hopeful there won't be another un-democratic state, but it's a plausible and real fear there won't. Granted, I think that the real wish of any western government will be that no one will remember who helped keep Mubarak there.

Granted, it's rather amusing the focus of the media is on Eygpt despite everything tacking place in the rest of the middle east. Large amounts of the region are facing an uprise, hopefully a successful one.

The reason why the focus on Egypt is so intense is because of how important Egypt is as a nation. It's traditionally the centre of the Arab world. The fall of Mubarak will have other Arab dictators shaking in their boots, it's a very ill omen for them.



Joelcool7 said:
elticker said:
 


oh yah did you see the video of the car of the US embassy running down protesters,

As Kaz said it was stolen. But even if it wasn't did you see the video's of Egyptian protestors attacking pretty much anyone foreign? CTV, CBC, Fox, CNN all were reporting that their journalists were being attacked by Egyptian protestors. A group of Canadian journalists were pulled from their cars and the translator said the egyptians planned on killing them, luckily the army intervened and rescued them.

Canada, the US and other countries only supported the Egyptian Government all these years because they were the Government. You say Egyptian's don't like the US playing around with your countries affairs, as such what did you expect them to do? Come into Egypt topple the Government and insert democracy? Wouldn't that have been meddaling in your affairs? Or should the US have boycott your Government and sanctioned the shit out of it?

The US Canada and other governments respected Egypts soveirnty and did not meddle in your countries affairs anymore then any other country. Sure they signed peace agreements and trade but they always respected your countries independance.

Egyptians would be just as mad if America meddled and intervened militarily to instal democracy. The US and Canada helped get Mubarak to step down. They have done everything they could for the egyptian people.

 

P.S- which University in Canada you going too?

actually mubaraks fucked the US. They ordered him ot step down and give power to sulieman on thursday, he instead gave it to the army on thursday but his son edited the clip so that he didn't resign and give power to sulieman. that was on thursday, the next day sulieman read the speach which gave power to the army and both army generals in control, al musheer tantawy and al fariq anan don't like israel as they have fought against them in the 1973 war. 

Waw what accusation you give us, these were the secret police who were attacking reporters, let me ask you a question if it was us the people attacking news reporters then why wasn't the american embassy destroyed or israeli embassy for this matter, why wheren't protesters burning israeli and american flags, why weren't we holding anti american signs? give me a reason for why we didn't do that and would attack news reporters.

im applied for U of T for biological science along with western ontario, algoma for computer science and waterloo for mechanical.