yes he said he always died night one.

And I knew he had said it before I asked.

You're not the slightest bit intrigued that I asked him that question and he left and never answered it?
You're not the slightest bit curious how the "NEW" radish, can not know things he's done in previous games?

@ radish:  You had said "Would you believe that I'm actually considered good on the other sites? :p"

Which sites would those be.  Clearly you don't mean ONM? 

Well, I'll give you that... Are you saying you would not push?

What's your opinion of what I did? I don't think I've heard you comment on it at all...but perhaps I'm wrong.
I'll go check again.

yes he said he always died night one.

And I knew he had said it before I asked.

You're not the slightest bit intrigued that I asked him that question and he left and never answered it?
You're not the slightest bit curious how the "NEW" radish, can not know things he's done in previous games?

3) Yes, now I am as unconfirmable as anyone else that hasn't been investigated by a confirmed cop come endgame. There's a better reason it'd be stupid though. Anyway, what are you getting at with the bolded? I don't understand it.

I already explained why I waited until now to claim. I knew I'd be putting myself in a hot seat, but really it was the best thing to do. If I'm going to be lynched then I will fight against it tooth and nail; however, at least this way it wouldn't mean a wasted investigation AND outing the cop for no reason.

5) You're welcome, I have nothing to hide. I'm not worried about the HoS, except that it sounds like you're just going to vote me after finding another alien, if the game isn't simply won there.

that you basically waisted time for the town... it was clear you would not have a definite conclusion (or at least one that made sense to me) when you had many "didn't notice".

I'm a little more interested in the fact that you apparently worked a lie into a question.  That's hardcore.  (You knew he'd mentioned it before, yet asked why he "only now" revealed the information.)

And frankly, I think it's entirely believable that he would forget whether he's given certain specific information before, as opposed to talking about his ONM mafia participation generally.  Furhtermore, unless you can show me evidence otherwise, I think this is actually new information, and therefore his revelation is exactly what he claimed it was. 

Also, you may notice that his new information contradicts his old information.  But this is consistent with his known tendency in his first game to lie to make himself look better (as a townie, being a townie).  I firmly think he's gotten over that unfortunate habit, and what he told us here rings true to me. 

On the other hand, it's worth asking why he bothered to say it in the first place...

yeah, i was just playing with him a bit. Radish is a genuine curiosity to me. He hammered 2 aliens  without even knowing it last game,