By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
noname2200 said:
theprof00 said:

Given my gambit, it's only logical that trash is mafia.

I don't believe anyone saw it as a clue.

This was part of my plan that I'll divulge at the end, but I believe firmly that she is.

 

Also, I'm going to give away one part of the "trap".

ABC's reasoning about someone noticing republic was doctor was complete bullshit. I read it as soon as I saw him post that, and it's the most flimsy evidence ever. Linkz almost gave it away by questioning the whole validity of the thing, but trash...trash took it as an opportunity to get ABC.

I really hope this doesn't backfire on me, and I promise I will never do a trap ever again if I'm wrong.

Did you think that I was just joking about gambits?

vote: prof

I'm not going to change my vote, or even post anything other than another vote on prof at the start of each day, until prof is dead.  Your gambit's done exactly what most of them do: shitted up several pages of the day, introduced added confusion, and come up with inconclusive results ("guys, trash fell for my gambit, as shown by her voting just as adamantly now for ABC as she did over a week ago!").  Well done, and good luck with that.

Seconding prof's sentiments. I was waiting for a vote on prof from you after he first said he lied. You had no issues then when it was ABC on the chopping block. It's only after the table was turned a second time with trash being the main focus that you pull this.



Around the Network
Linkzmax said:
Linkzmax said: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3930178
trashleg said:

Also, It's very strange that you list me in Town and then noname in parenthesis, but then list us both again under Unknown. Did you just slip-up, because I can't see any way that you'd have us both under Town. Even if you were the cop and scanned me that wouldn't explain noname, or vice-versa. Why don't you have radish listed under any category either?

Requoted for attention. Obviously I knew trashleg couldn't have scanned me, though no comment whatsover on the possibility of her being the cop. It still seems odd to me that she put me in Town, and as in the quote nest above once again said she believes me to be a townie. As always, I can't self-analyze worth squat, but I don't think I've been playing differently which should make me "borderline" rather than a pro-town read. Going to need others' input on this, but it also feels like buddying up, which is just bizarre to me. Though trash, props for not jumping at the easy target.(me)

I also think her last post in which she gives her thoughts on all the townies was meant to disorient anyone looking for a connection after her flip.



Hephaestos said:
Linkzmax said:

1) I'm pretty sure I never questioned there being a cop in this game. If I had it was after the theory that Republic was killed because of a conversation about there being a doctor. I didn't want my insistance that there is a cop to come off as a sign that I am such.

2) I don't believe that's the case, but I'm sure that was directed elsewhere. However, you were actually correct about me being a bit nervous when you had voted me day one. I was worried about becoming suspicious on top of being considered a good player and getting scanned.

3) I'd say that's a valid statement. I was thinking someone might've scanned me and had been trying to make it to day three without having to out themselves, with the thinking being town is already down and needs to make up for it. That'd be quite risky though, and I haven't noticed anyone acting strangely towards me as I would expect if they had scanned me guilty.

4) Okay. That's indefensible though. Unless you'd like me to paraphrase the flavor from my role PM. I didn't even understand it's relevance until the night flavor, when it was revealed that the aliens control humans from within the heart. I have undergone a surgery which left a noticeable blemish on my chest. That's also why I still read the flavor as indicating Wonk could've been an alien.

5) Again, I don't think protown roles would be hinted, and set ups feel like something scum would do to later fakeclaim. On top of that, I figured that I am the spice and there wouldn't be anything else. Finally, the fact that you weren't targeted last night still rings bells with me, but that's more day two than one.(And it's why you stayed at HoS while trash dropped to an FoS)

6) It is still something I'm considering, but with Stefl's post I'm leaning heavily towards a 3-man(or woman) scumteam. I think I was included to prevent a game of "follow the cop" while still having the powerful combo of doc and cop. I wouldn't be entirely surprised if there is additional town power, but every claim should be scrutinized.


1) well more asking the town than you but thanks for the foresight.

2) same, but thanks for the revelation.

3) Well you'll probably get lynched down the line regardless.

4) not asking for a defence, as you say it's indefensible and 3).

5) As I said I don't really have the time to go back today, but i'll look at your reaction to the discutions where I talked about "spice". In any case I can fairly well understand my not dying by being to much in view yesterday to be deemed a power role and too likely to be a suspect today to be worth a lynch. Proff spoke about the reasons why him you and I didn't get lynched and it seems like killing one of you two would have had a better outcome for mafia by sentencing me. I'm not all that convinced the mafia had that reflexion but i'm not especially surprised they didn't kill me, especially if they saw the doc clue on wonk.

6) oh yeah I forgot about stefl's post at the begining.... it's also true he didn't joke about confessing (if I recall). In any case yes, any claim should be scrutinized, i'm trying to lay the blueprint for that with questions 1) and 2).

3) Not sure I like this as it implies that there's no chance of me being night killed. I think it's unlikely and I don't want to get into reasons, but there's nothing preventing it from happening.

5) Not stopping you or anyone else from looking back into it, but here was my reply on the "spice", which was also when I voted for you. http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3919375



theprof00 said:

 it actually was a joke because I anticipated town win after Heph. :P

And yes, WIFOM, but how can you make an accusation when it's foundation makes no sense? I'm just telling it like it is.

I would be lynched. Noname would push for it because he's against anyone playing in a way that he doesn't consider the "right" way, Heph would push, as after the flip he was seriously tunneling on me, FF would probably throw in a "sure, why not"-vote since he always suspects me and also doesn't like gambits.

I think I'd have Radish, ABC defending me, and you'd probably go whatever way you thought made sense.

But yeah, if trash flipped town, I could see at least three people ready to vote me, which is one away from majority.

 

EDIT: snipped quote boxes, 

Also, Yes, I understand what you mean by extra night. I was hoping you didn't notice the post, because after thinking about it, you're completely right :P

Then as I said, you can disregard the rest of that post.

You may be right with people that would be ready to lynch you, but there's no telling who'd even be around at that point. I dunno where I would stand, but it's useless for me to ponder it now.

Like I said, we were both right in a way. The round would extend to another day, but really it's only because today is given up.

Here's your flower: @}~'~~i~~ :P (P.S. It's dead!)



so now the question over me is cop v alien?

why can't i just be a normal townie, is it really one extreme or the other?

linkz, im not trying to buddy. i haven't played with you before so i dont know about previous playstyle but this game i get a townie vibe. and with your roleclaim, why is this a bad thing?

 

also, what does WIFOM mean? and when will you guys stop using acronyms i dont understand?!



Highwaystar101 said: trashleg said that if I didn't pay back the money she leant me, she would come round and break my legs... That's why people call her trashleg, because she trashes the legs of the people she loan sharks money to.
Around the Network
radishhead said:

After some thought, I see the appeal of no-lynching today.

Unvote: ABClown

Vote: No lynch

Was it independent thought that made you decide this, and if so what was your reasoning?

Or had you decided to read the thread after posting your thoughts that we should still lynch, and noticed the good points on why no lynch is the best option?



trashleg said:

so now the question over me is cop v alien?

why can't i just be a normal townie, is it really one extreme or the other?

linkz, im not trying to buddy. i haven't played with you before so i dont know about previous playstyle but this game i get a townie vibe. and with your roleclaim, why is this a bad thing?

 

also, what does WIFOM mean? and when will you guys stop using acronyms i dont understand?!


WIFOM= We Inform Females of Our Manliness?



19:44:34 Skeezer METAL GEAR ONLINE
19:44:36 Skeezer FAILURE
19:44:51 ABadClown You're right!
19:44:55 ABadClown Hur hur hur
19:45:01 Skeezer i meant
19:45:04 Skeezer YOU ARE A FAILKURE
19:45:08 Skeezer FAILURE*
trashleg said:

so now the question over me is cop v alien?

why can't i just be a normal townie, is it really one extreme or the other?

linkz, im not trying to buddy. i haven't played with you before so i dont know about previous playstyle but this game i get a townie vibe. and with your roleclaim, why is this a bad thing?

 

also, what does WIFOM mean? and when will you guys stop using acronyms i dont understand?!

All I knew/know is that there was no way you could have scanned me IF you are the cop. "though no comment whatsover on the possibility of her being the cop." I'm not suggesting you are the cop, nor am I ruling it out. I don't know, and I don't care to know unless you do claim.

That's fine, I'm just telling you the impression I have. I do realize it's our first game together, and that's why I wanted others' input on if I give off a townie vibe. I'm just not very trusting of those that seem to trust me, because they shouldn't have a reason to. As for the roleclaim, I'm just trying to put myself into someone else's shoes, and I'd be very suspicious of someone claiming miller. I don't understand why people seem okay to just move right along.

Very sorry about the acronym, I've been trying hard to write them out and explain them, but I was rushing through posts. It stands for Wine in Front of Me. http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Wifom should explain better than I can.



Linkzmax said:

theprof00 said:

 it actually was a joke because I anticipated town win after Heph. :P

And yes, WIFOM, but how can you make an accusation when it's foundation makes no sense? I'm just telling it like it is.

I would be lynched. Noname would push for it because he's against anyone playing in a way that he doesn't consider the "right" way, Heph would push, as after the flip he was seriously tunneling on me, FF would probably throw in a "sure, why not"-vote since he always suspects me and also doesn't like gambits.

I think I'd have Radish, ABC defending me, and you'd probably go whatever way you thought made sense.

But yeah, if trash flipped town, I could see at least three people ready to vote me, which is one away from majority.

 

EDIT: snipped quote boxes, 

Also, Yes, I understand what you mean by extra night. I was hoping you didn't notice the post, because after thinking about it, you're completely right :P

Then as I said, you can disregard the rest of that post.

You may be right with people that would be ready to lynch you, but there's no telling who'd even be around at that point. I dunno where I would stand, but it's useless for me to ponder it now.

Like I said, we were both right in a way. The round would extend to another day, but really it's only because today is given up.

Here's your flower: @}~'~~i~~ :P (P.S. It's dead!)

Though useless, it's fun to speculate who might be killed and for what reason.

I just felt really dumb, especially after writing through it the way that I did. lolz

also, thank you for the dead flora.



Linkzmax said:
radishhead said:

After some thought, I see the appeal of no-lynching today.

Unvote: ABClown

Vote: No lynch

Was it independent thought that made you decide this, and if so what was your reasoning?

Or had you decided to read the thread after posting your thoughts that we should still lynch, and noticed the good points on why no lynch is the best option?

I figured that since the option of lynching today was widely opposed, it was worth reading the arguments against it (I suppose that I should have read them beforehand) - it seems worth the chance. Although I'm not 100% sure that there is a cop, and it seems to me that the current state of the round is debating whether this is true or not.



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~