By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Would Metroid 3DS sell?

 

Would Metroid 3DS sell?

Yes, it would achieve what the others failed 48 65.75%
 
No, it wouldn't sell muc... 25 34.25%
 
Total:73
Khuutra said:
jarrod said:

You might disagree, but I feel my own experience is "reasonable".  And frankly that's what I'm speaking to... after completing both I feel what people generally didn't like about Fusion was dialed down in Zero Mission (linearity, segmentation, story, etc).  I guess you can argue against the ultimate market impact of that with lowered scores, sales archives, or whatever, but that's really beside the point.  I just see a similar opportunity here, no more, no less.  Sakamoto's not blind, there's a track record, and after the savage treatment Other M got, I'd naturally expect a much more dialed back, more conservative approach from his team next time.  That sound reasonable?

OT, now I have to buy DOA Dimensions.  The Ridley battle was really the highlight of Other M imo.

That there will be some change? Certainly, that's a reasonable assumption; it's one of the only constants in the series.

Lack of impact is the entire point, though, because it means a Zero Mission-style remake probably isn't in the cards, regardless of what Sakamoto would want to do with it.

A dialing back I can certainly see, but I would hesitate to assume the sort of dialing back it would be; Fusion is the most successful 2D Metroid since the original, and this fact can't be discounted. The face of the 3DS Metroid is going to be determined by what Nintendo sees as factors that makes these games sell, and Sakamoto is far from the only voice in that argument.

I don't think the market impact would correlate entirely though... there's too many different variables now, not least of which involves an entire system transition (as I'm pretty sure no expects the next Metroid to be a Wii title).  In every instance we've seen there's been a comparable degree of same platform fatigue for this series. Zero Mission might've sold half what Fusion did, but so did Echoes following Prime, and it's looking like it'll be true for Other M following Corruption also.

And leaning towards a more conservative approach from SPD1 isn't exactly much of a leap. That's (in part) why I think another remake might make some sense, it's an inherently more conservative approach from the outset then (though obviously it could lead in controversial directions).  Plus, at least Metroid 2 could use it, it's pretty clunky... I can see how a Super Metroid remake might go badly for them though, if they went that way instead.

And where did I say Sakamoto's the only voice here?  I'm pretty sure there's going to be heavy input and consideration from Iwata, Miyamoto, and various management above him, as well as Hosokawa, Hayashi, and the rest of the team below him.



Around the Network

Hm, after having looked through VGC's Metroid sales data (assuming it's more or less accurate) it really looks like the problem is making a Metroid that will sell well in both Japan and the west. One seem to prefer 2D (incl. OM) Metroid while the other prefers Prime.

To make a Metroid that is huge saleswise Nintendo would need to either pretty much ignore one of the two markets and go all-in for the other one (Prime) or make a Metroid that nicely blends both styles (has yet to happen).