By this I mean take the sales of all of 360's holiday exclusives and PS3's holiday exclusive and see who's higher.

Here are the for past years:

2010: 360 had Kinect, Halo Reach, and Fable 3. PS3 had GT5 and MOVE. X360 was higher

2009: 360 had Forza 3, Halo ODST, and L4D2. PS3 had Uncharted 2, R&C:ACiT, and GOW Collection. X360 was higher

2008: 360 had Gears 2, Fable 2, and L4D1. PS3 had LBP, SOCOM, Motorstorm 2 and Resistance 2. X360 was higher

I won't even go to 2007 and 2006.  

I will only count the sales of games that released in September - December. 

In 2011, PS3 looks to have Uncharted 3, Resistance 3, Twisted Metal, some Move games and Ratchet & Clank (maybe TLG). X360 looks to have Gears of War 3, Forza Motorsport 4, some Kinect games and maybe XCOM & Kingdoms & Halo Remake?

Will this be the first year where PS3 combined exclusives > 360 combined exclusives for the holidays or will X360 shine again.

I know it's too early to determine which games will be announced, but I just wanted everyone's opinion because I thought it was interesting that X360 exclusive software outperformed PS3's everywhere holiday.

ps3 in 2009 ho;idays sale more than xbox360

ps3 was higher

sorry holidays

In 2011 you'll say 360 had Kinect, Halo remake, Gears 3, etc.

So no, I don't think so.

Halo: ODST: 4.4m

Forza 3: 2.0m

L4D2: 2.3m

Uncharted 2: 2.6m

R&C:ACiT: 0.7m

GOWC: 0.5m

X360 SW sales were much higher than PS3's.

PS: BY SW, I mean the sales of games

OH, how did I forget Kinect games, so much for my thread.

As for the Halo remake, I Don't Know, I'll label it as a maybe.

aha sorry i thought you mean hw sales

i  think gears of war 3 well be the highest in 2011

the highest between ps360 exclusive

Even without the Halo remake you have to consider that every game for Kinect is pretty much exclusive. Thats a lot of titles!

True, I'm surprised I didn't think of that when I made the thread.