Apparently you aren't the only one. GOW and Wonk both thought that it was a genuine opinion. Sarcasm doesn't translate well on the internet.

Can you explain how my comment not being sarcastic would lead to GOW retreating?

Sarcasm generally isn't looked at as a positive quality, so I'm not sure why you think prof would offer that as an excuse. I agree his attacks on me were relatively weak, but it's what I'd expect of prof from my limited experiences. I see that as a confused townie just trying to gauge the reaction/non-reaction before going full force. I'm not sure of prof's alignment myself, but the interaction hasn't raised any scumflags for me.

@Prof
If you want to provide whatever response you had in there in a readable form I will look it over. Until then I don't bother with people who type inside a quote window, nor people who presume they can make demands of me.

Just want to point out that the person you were thinking of was zexen: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3815401

Very interesting point though. I'd never thought to look for that.

or mafia might be hiding by discussing things that will lead nowhere... so they don't appear to be lurking.

it's true the response is more fit to a lurker's list than a no post yet list, still the rest of it is a call for real discution rather than bickering on facetious points (word of the day)

I read it as "well give them something to talk about then"

in any case, this point is a bit facetious itself, if you want to pursue him on this, you can. I just felt that it was a dead end for both of you to hammer each other on this. (and although i fosed you, you're not the type to do slips easily, so no point in letting it go)

Emphasizing the bolded because I do NOT want to show you that the exact same thing would happen if there's 7 mafia. Extending an extra day has absolutely nothing to do with the number of mafia, but merely the town as a whole being odd or even numbered.

i briefly reread so i guess i missed it. it's an angle to consider but not my main one on him.

_let's lynch

_you've overused this agressive townie strat already, lay low

_ maybe i should lay low

i guess you can still call it sarcastic.... but that is litteraly what poped in my mind when i read.

provided there is only one kill, a no lynch extends 1/2 day whatever the number of players. if a doc saves, same thing. Number of mafia is linked to town size as you count the extra townies to mafia, with each being a half day. killing a mafia extends by a full day.

So basically a no lynch day one can gain a day with a doc save or a second no lynch (like to reduce town to 3vs1 instead of 4vs1 on the last day.)

Maybe you're thinking of my post to MG? http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3815462

In my eyes you apply presure to a random person at the beginning of the game, often people that haven't done anything (yet), then later into the game you just do the same thing, it is very good if a mafia gives in to your presure, but sometimes you even presure townies into making mistakes which gets them lynched ultimately. Also to me you seem like you never have a specific target (be it pro or contra town) it just looks like you enjoy "tormenting" and make other players insecure, so that your goal is more playing with people then playing the game. It is fine as long as you get scum with this method, but to me you always appear as scum, so I have to make excuses to myself for not voting for you. This would benefit you immensly when you happen to be scum in the future (I think I never played with you when you were scum), because then I, again, would make excuses to myself. Finally your playstyle looks to me like one big preperation for when you are scum.

So... that is what I think of your playstyle... and why I don't like it...