By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - OUTCH ! GT5 first french review : 14/20 !!!!!

dsister on 23 November 2010
darthdevidem01 said:
Grandia said:

jeuxvideo.com is the biggest gaming Mag of France, I think GT5 will be a big Flop. GT5 might be the biggest Flop of this Generation.

Define "flop" in terms of GT5 sales....

I wanna know what you expect.


Only 8 million! Sony will quit the console race in shame :o



Sig thanks to Saber! :D 

Around the Network
mrpapaye on 23 November 2010
4k1x3r said:
geddesmond2 said:
mrpapaye said:
dsister said:
geddesmond2 said:

Oh no a french website that knowbody cares about gave GT5 a 14 out of 20. Quick what will we do?

...


See Libellu? Yeah he's French and if you saw he said it's the biggest gaming website in France. Which I believe the game is hugely popular there, no?


Hello

From what i know, its not only the biggest french gaming site but even the biggest European gaming site...

The strangest thing is that this site usually gives easily high notes to big games, i was sure the minimum they would give to GT5 would be 17/20 and i was pretty sure it would be 18 or 19.  

I hope for GT fans that the game is really better than this but now i'm beginning to think that i will end at 70 something on Metacritic.

Bye.


Well I live in Europe and I never even heard of that website and I'm sure other people would agree with me on that one so how is it Europes biggest. Are you going by your opinions of the site or do people actually reconize it as Europes biggest website because from where I am in Europe Eurogamer is seen as the biggest gaming website.

Biggest in France and that's all. And you know why, because all the x360/PS3/Wii trolls are going there because they know they'll have people that they can troll. Even the news writers are trolls, the way they write the news etc. And I can't say it enough, Rivaol, the dude who made the review, never gave a good review to a PS3 game, even the Naruto one which was awesome he gave it a relatively bad score. This dude sucks and the only explanation to this shit is that they want views, because everyone will talk about their review (see it works even here). Fuck them, they want money and that's all. Shittiest website ever, and I mean it.

Strange, i dont know him but i have just checked his ps3 tests and...  :

Modnation racers : 16, Motorstorm pacific rift : 17, Ratchet : 17, Uncharted 2 : 19



Zones : I still don't understand all the love for Blizzard, what was the last game they developed worth playing?
ConnorJCP on 23 November 2010
libellule said:
darthdevidem01 said:
RAZurrection said:
darthdevidem01 said:

What different standards though?

At this present time in the gaming market according to what kind of odd standards does GT5 deserve a 15/20?

4/5 of all cars are PS2 quality- Do you think that deserves higher then a 75? 

Does this?

In the least you can admit that GT5's graphics are inconsistant, we know this from the Premium/Standard division.

If any other next gen game had best graphics ever for the first 2 levels and last gen visuals for the last 8 levels, it wouldn't get a perfect (or high) graphics score either.

 

.......

..........

..............

Are you sure that image is from GT5?

A few guys on the PS Forums said grfx are inconsistent but I thought they were being picky

I hope that image is fake.

actually, it could be (it is) a std car on trial mountain (old track)

so yeah, I think it is GT5

That is Gran Turismo 4.
I can almost guarantee, i was playing it yesterday and i was versing the same car on the same map and it looked the exact same as that picture.

Unless they didn't change anything for GT5.



Smart Men answer questions, Wise men ask questions.
Gamers play games, True Gamers support Gaming

geddesmond2 on 23 November 2010
mrpapaye said:
geddesmond2 said:
mrpapaye said:
dsister said:
geddesmond2 said:

Oh no a french website that knowbody cares about gave GT5 a 14 out of 20. Quick what will we do?

...


See Libellu? Yeah he's French and if you saw he said it's the biggest gaming website in France. Which I believe the game is hugely popular there, no?


Hello

From what i know, its not only the biggest french gaming site but even the biggest European gaming site...

The strangest thing is that this site usually gives easily high notes to big games, i was sure the minimum they would give to GT5 would be 17/20 and i was pretty sure it would be 18 or 19.  

I hope for GT fans that the game is really better than this but now i'm beginning to think that i will end at 70 something on Metacritic.

Bye.


Well I live in Europe and I never even heard of that website and I'm sure other people would agree with me on that one so how is it Europes biggest. Are you going by your opinions of the site or do people actually reconize it as Europes biggest website because from where I am in Europe Eurogamer is seen as the biggest gaming website.


I dont really like this site so this is not about my opinion, my favorite french ones being Gamekult and Gamersyde but it clearly is a very big site, i'm a retailer and 4 out of 5 of my customers give me the impression that they know only JeuxVideo.com

Ok I'm not trying to be smart or anything but how exactly do they give you that impression. Do you ask every customer or does 4 out of 5 of your customers just decide to tell you they use Jeuxvideo because either of them would be very strange



mrpapaye on 23 November 2010

Well that's quite simple, a lot of people talk about what they have read about the games they want to buy, they often tell me on what site they have read it and i often ask them if they dont.   In the end, i'm sure at least half my customers have told me once what site they read mostly.



Zones : I still don't understand all the love for Blizzard, what was the last game they developed worth playing?
Around the Network
Squilliam on 23 November 2010

Why are people so up in arms about this?

Either its an attempt to drive hits, so troll article wins and fanboys lose. Alternatively it is a legitimate review and the person just has a different opinion which is allowed. So fanboys are losers in that case.

So do the fanboys lose? Are the fanboys losers? Both?

Seriously now, trolls bait fanboys. If there were no fanboys then there would be noone to troll.

 



Tease.

geddesmond2 on 23 November 2010
ConnorJCP said:
libellule said:
darthdevidem01 said:
RAZurrection said:
darthdevidem01 said:

What different standards though?

At this present time in the gaming market according to what kind of odd standards does GT5 deserve a 15/20?

4/5 of all cars are PS2 quality- Do you think that deserves higher then a 75? 

Does this?

In the least you can admit that GT5's graphics are inconsistant, we know this from the Premium/Standard division.

If any other next gen game had best graphics ever for the first 2 levels and last gen visuals for the last 8 levels, it wouldn't get a perfect (or high) graphics score either.

 

.......

..........

..............

Are you sure that image is from GT5?

A few guys on the PS Forums said grfx are inconsistent but I thought they were being picky

I hope that image is fake.

actually, it could be (it is) a std car on trial mountain (old track)

so yeah, I think it is GT5

That is Gran Turismo 4.
I can almost guarantee, i was playing it yesterday and i was versing the same car on the same map and it looked the exact same as that picture.

Unless they didn't change anything for GT5.


Hold on I missed that. Is he trying to pass that screenshot off as GT5? LMAO



ConnorJCP on 23 November 2010
geddesmond2 said:
ConnorJCP said:
libellule said:
darthdevidem01 said:
RAZurrection said:
darthdevidem01 said:

What different standards though?

At this present time in the gaming market according to what kind of odd standards does GT5 deserve a 15/20?

4/5 of all cars are PS2 quality- Do you think that deserves higher then a 75? 

Does this?

In the least you can admit that GT5's graphics are inconsistant, we know this from the Premium/Standard division.

If any other next gen game had best graphics ever for the first 2 levels and last gen visuals for the last 8 levels, it wouldn't get a perfect (or high) graphics score either.

 

.......

..........

..............

Are you sure that image is from GT5?

A few guys on the PS Forums said grfx are inconsistent but I thought they were being picky

I hope that image is fake.

actually, it could be (it is) a std car on trial mountain (old track)

so yeah, I think it is GT5

That is Gran Turismo 4.
I can almost guarantee, i was playing it yesterday and i was versing the same car on the same map and it looked the exact same as that picture.

Unless they didn't change anything for GT5.


Hold on I missed that. Is he trying to pass that screenshot off as GT5? LMAO

Yea, he is.
Pathetic isnt it.



Smart Men answer questions, Wise men ask questions.
Gamers play games, True Gamers support Gaming

GameOver22 on 23 November 2010
Squilliam said:

Why are people so up in arms about this?

Either its an attempt to drive hits, so troll article wins and fanboys lose. Alternatively it is a legitimate review and the person just has a different opinion which is allowed. So fanboys are losers in that case.

So do the fanboys lose? Are the fanboys losers? Both?

Seriously now, trolls bait fanboys. If there were no fanboys then there would be noone to troll.

It could also just be a poor review. Not all opinions are of the same quality. Someone can write a serious review that lacks legitimacy. This goes for both positive and negative reviews.



NiKKoM on 23 November 2010
ConnorJCP said:
geddesmond2 said:
ConnorJCP said:
libellule said:

actually, it could be (it is) a std car on trial mountain (old track)

so yeah, I think it is GT5

That is Gran Turismo 4.
I can almost guarantee, i was playing it yesterday and i was versing the same car on the same map and it looked the exact same as that picture.

Unless they didn't change anything for GT5.


Hold on I missed that. Is he trying to pass that screenshot off as GT5? LMAO

Yea, he is.
Pathetic isnt it.

Neh he isn't... http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=375000&page=169
(somewhere there thread is huge)
it seems PD copied Trail Mountain from GT4 in GT5... >_>



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!)