I think he is trying to indirectly influence people toward a lynch of Radish, while I agree that some of Radishes behavour is off, its hardly to the point where one can justify bandwagoning him toward being lynched.

Bah, I'll be back. Got a fire call.

no, but you joined the bandwagon so lazily, and some of your posts to me seem like an indirect to way to convince people of your vote (even though the reasoning is poor), the fact you then voted for me as a revenge vote, really only hightens my feeling that you are scum.

also;

Kantor - " I couldn't care less about your silly FoS. Were I a mafioso, would I really start shivering in my boots at an FoS when somebody else was on L-3? The time at which I finished reading through the thread was the time after you posted your Finger of Suspicion. Coincidence, nothing more."

I really find it suspicious when people talk about what they would do if they were scum, to me it just seems like a double bluff

Please excuse my exaggeration.

why? one of the reasons people gave for voting for Radish was just that, his "exageration and bending of the truth"

When you voted for me, that was cause for concern.

that just sounds like a backtrack and an excuse...

It's an extremely baseless bandwagon vote. It just has more base than any other bandwagon vote.

and this eliminates its suspiciousness how exactly?

add to this your inconsitent behvour toward other players and voting earlier on, your actions all reek of scum to me.

I have already mentioned that I have an eye on some of the things both theProf and radishead have done...at this stage though, Kantor seems a much more suspect player, it really doesnt help his cause that you and I think it was dtewi were keen to attack me for voting for him

please nobody vote, I'm working on a post tally.

Going ol' school.

I'd read over the post with radishhead twice more before voting but by spending so long doing that I was up much latter than I wanted to be so I went for what was true a mob mentality.  If I say I'm using the reasons other people are using it's still mob mentality.  It wasn't a vote because I wanted to see blood, just trying to play the game and participate with the schedule I have.  It was midnight between a shift that ran late and before I needed to get to bed to be up for a shift that ran early.  I don't want to lurk I want to participate but at the same time. I didn't have the time to really get into a thorough argument for those that I suspect.  So I chose an easier way for me to participate.  Vote for someone with some contradictions.

Having read all the comments since this as well I have some more to add

radisheads problem was making an all or never statement and those are so easy to get caught up in because there are exceptions.  If he had sadly he doesn't like to lynch first day but can potentially be persuaded it would have not left him so open for someone to see the contradiction.

as for me I'm not against a first day lynch and not totally in favor either.  However would be more inclined to suspect those that are strongly in either camp.  Which is why have my suspicions of gow and prof.  One just wanted a day one kill the other trying to show that it won't matter if it's wrong by using only worst case scenario.  I put those as a bit more suspicious than those who say no lynch first day.  So although Radish is not as high as on my suspicions as those two it fit within my criteria and further comments made it worthy of a vote.

Now had my vote been the final vote that would lynch him I would probably have waited a bit longer for it but at that point I think there were 5 or 6 so there still would have needed to have been 2 or 3 more.  Plus the extra vote was more likely to put pressure on Radish to get him to talk and although things he said made me feel sympathetic and want to take my vote back added to you and metal gear saying it's scummy I'm sticking to it.  Not because he failed to be consistent but because what he claimed to be consistently (initially) would be a way of just always trying to look like a townie without necessarily trying to be a townie.

I agree with prof on that last point about GoW.  Other than that, I dunno about all this junk.  Homer comes in and make points that strike me as questionable, and a lot of dilly-dallying when radish is probably just going to die when the timer runs out anyway.  (This is outdated; more recent replies are pretty interesting.) 

@ Linkzmax:  All I meant was that I don't really have prime suspects at this time given the innocence of radish.  In the morning, with another body, I'll reexamine the situation more closely with that in mind and I'm sure we'll manage to find a suspect or two.  And if there's no body ... yay!

Kantor and homer both have a little bit of suspicion on them, but nothing that makes me want to take my vote off radish at this time. 

Oh yes, wonktonodi.  To ease my suspicions of YOU, tell me:  what were those suspicions in your earlier post? 

Actually, radish was at L3 when Kantor voted for him :/