By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - VGC Mafia Round 22 Game Thread

If there is a cop, do not come forward.



Around the Network

I have the strangest feeling that linkz huge post about GoW is just one big set-up to make us believe he's town.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

holly crap ! /facepalm.....

 

hat please turn on your paranoia mode, the town needs suspects ^^



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO

be back on later

I voted heph, in case ff shows up.

I'll do it again just in case.

vote: Heph



We've got a pretty major one as-is, Heph.

Though I'm always willing to have more.



Around the Network

And yes, for the record, I intend to see Hephaestos die today.

Simple question he can't answer.

First, this:

Vote: Hephaestos

Now, to repeat the question:

Heph, you have said that you are a nameless townie. Are you nameless according to the guidelines that I put down earlier?

Actually, now that I'm thinking about it, you better just roleclaim. You already said you're vanilla, so there's nothing to lose.

Hephaestos, ROLE CLAIM.



theprof00 said:

My top three are hephaestos, SAK, and kantor

Heph is fighting very strongly for the nameless townie situation. He came in to defend linkzmax by saying he also had no name, and then when linkz cleared up that he was only inferring what therepublic was saying, suddenly heph was the only vanilla without a name. 

Kantor seems very cautious and mentioned "sailor moon names" as well, and could have been a slip. Conversely, therepublic, who called kantor out on it, made just a very very cautious poke when he brought the post in question up. His post came off to me as "so, does this make anyone want to vote for kantor?". So, FoS on both of them. (more on therepublic, than kantor)

SAK asked a metagame question just like truck did, which in itself is scummy. However, he never really pursued any followup to it.  To me, mafia are the type to dip their toes in the water and leave it at that. The way he brought up lynching lurkers was very similar to that. Additionally, he was the second person to bring up meta-rules, and that comes off to me as an imitation of contributing (thanks to linkz for pointing that out).

 

Also guys, I really need to point something out too. Linkzmax recent post, was, well...dubious. I highly question his GoW assertion for several reasons. 1) His actions did not come off as scummy at all. That would have been total amateur mafia, and I think linkz would have understood that. However, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt because he doesn't know our players and their experience.

Secondly, making an entire case against GoW DURING THE NIGHT tells me a couple things, and I'll put them in the way I understand it.

A) He wants me to think that he's productive.
B) He wants me to think that he's suspicious of GoW
C) He wants me to think that when he wrote it, GoW is still in the game.

From looking at the way linkzmax plays, it seems like he has a lot of experience, and I wouldn't put it past him that what he wrote up above is a cover. Additionally, republic has posted a lot, and yet he somehow has no read. 

 

For now, I'm voting Heph.

Vote: Hephaestos


Since you questioned my lack of a response last time, I'll answer you directly here.
1) I really do have to chalk this up to a lack of my experience and it makes me question my take on everything so far. I'm not the only one that laid suspicions on him nor thought he had scummy behavior, but I didn't factor that it would be far too obvious or amateurish.

There was far more to my post then my case against GoW. I really wish I could've put that post out there before it went into night one even though I think it would've made me look just as bad, but what's done is done.
A) I'm not trying to make you think I'm productive. I'm going to be as productive as I can to help any way I can.
B) I was suspicious of GoW. Obviously that suspicions was dead wrong. If I didn't write it up and post it then I think I would've been questioned on why I FoSed day one anyway.
C) You're implying I'm scum and knew he'd be dead. All I can say is I didn't. The other option is I wrote it all after night one ended, but it took hours to compile everything, so no that isn't the case.

I already went over the experience thing, but with the Republic I had a miniscule scum vibe. Didn't sit right with me that he prodded Kantor and when I asked him what he meant about it he dissappeared.

On your vote for Heph, I believe he's town right now so I'm not willing to get behind that.

SAK I do have suspicions of, but I think I'd need more than what you and I brought up.

I don't think the Kantor "Sailor Moon names" is anything to go off of.

 

@Homer
If you're reading the thread you'd know who is idling. For the second time, read the thread.
Heph clearly claimed being a nameless vanilla townie. For the third time, READ THE THREAD.



Khuutra said:

And yes, for the record, I intend to see Hephaestos die today.

Simple question he can't answer.

First, this:

Vote: Hephaestos

Now, to repeat the question:

Heph, you have said that you are a nameless townie. Are you nameless according to the guidelines that I put down earlier?

Actually, now that I'm thinking about it, you better just roleclaim. You already said you're vanilla, so there's nothing to lose.

Hephaestos, ROLE CLAIM.

which question? the one I answered in a post to trucks about 100 posts ago?



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO

oh and for the role, I have none.... obviously



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO

Hephaestos said:

holly crap ! /facepalm.....

 

hat please turn on your paranoia mode, the town needs suspects ^^

Well I hate to say it, but it was obvious by the way he was playing that GoW had a power role, which is why I was ignoring his vote on me yesterday. I was trying to avoid  putting too much attention on the situation; praying that others (scum) would overlook his identical playing pattern. Last time he was randomly voting first day,he turned up Cop. And for a second there, I honestly thought he was the Cop again this game. And if I saw it, I'm sure scum saw it too. Which is why he's dead now.

IIRC, GoW fos'ed or voted  Silver-Tiger at the end of the day, I want to say it's a revenge kill, but it's probably a set-up from the mafia. Then again, it could possibly be a set-up for me.

Aside from of being paranoid of Khuutra,well, I'm sorry to say that you're at the top of my list right now. I'm gonna have to side with prof on this one.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson