Demon's Souls deserves the number 1 spot since it is easily the best "next" gen console game to date.
Demon's Souls deserves the number 1 spot since it is easily the best "next" gen console game to date.
| Ssenkahdavic said: Demon's Souls deserves the number 1 spot since it is easily the best "next" gen console game to date. |
-____-
...
Not really...
I don't see why it would win anyways since Uncharted 2 won GOTY by IGN in 2009.
Boutros said:
-____- ... Not really... I don't see why it would win anyways since Uncharted 2 won GOTY by IGN in 2009. |
Of course UC2 will win.
What will win and what deserves to win are not always the same.
Ssenkahdavic said:
Of course UC2 will win. What will win and what deserves to win are not always the same. |
It actually is the same thing. It's just a question of opinion.
And I hope IGN knows that this list should represent the opinion of the majority.
| Boutros said: Here's the rest so far: 20. Resistance: Fall of Man 19. Burnout Paradise 18. Borderlands 17. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare 16. Valkyria Chronicles
...CoD4 at #17 is insulting and makes this list extremely flawed already. It was rightfully #3 on the Xbox 360. And Borderlands is a bad game and it's wrong of them to give it so much credit. |
I agree, Cod4 is easily my favorite online game and the story was great too. It should be pretty high ( i am sure mw2 will be up at the top even though its crap). And Boarderlands is ok...
EVERY GAMERS WORST NIGHTMARE...THE TANGLING CABLES MONSTER!

Coffee is for closers!
im happy that resistance fall of man is their, same thing for valkyria chronicles even though i hated it.
Being in 3rd place never felt so good
| Ssenkahdavic said: Demon's Souls deserves the number 1 spot since it is easily the best "next" gen console game to date. |
HELL YEAH!
This is THE game, it DESERVES number one but its not as popular as the others which is a big shame.
- Wasteland - The Mission.
A Crack In Time Should be top 10! So should Modern Warfare. My guesses based on the list so far:
10. Heavy Rain/Uncharted
9. Killzone 2
8. Modern Warfare 2
7. GTA IV
6. Demon's Souls
5. God of War III
4. Red Dead Redemption
3. LittleBigPlanet
2. Uncharted 2
1. MGS4

| axumblade said: Ratchet & Clank is way too low. But I can see why they opted for Resistance to be a higher placing considering it was one of the first games on the PS3 to impress people. |
the list surprises everyone. its sad how psychonauts wasnt on the list of the 360. such a shame.
Being in 3rd place never felt so good
These lists are never a good idea, they just lead to arguments because no-one can really decide for themselves their own list of 25, let alone agree with somebody else's. However, as it is IGN it is bound to be very stupid in some way, but I will forgive them if they put Uncharted 2 top, where it belongs