By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 18 Game Thread

Okay, to clarify.

I haven't been trying to make a case for thinking that supermario, Vetteman or anybody else definitely isn't scum. I'm just making a case for who I think the Mafia A leader might be, because all the bad playing in this game recently has made it difficult to determine people's alignments from their behaviour alone. Vetteman made those ridiculously feeble bandwagons, and supermario has been defiantly erratic so much so that I'm left wondering if he's even trying to play the game at all. And they aren't the only ones either (silver-tiger being another recent example,) just perhaps the worst ones.

Honestly I'm at a loss in as far as determining who to vote for based on behaviour because we could vote for quite a few people right now. That's why I decided to try and look at things from another perspective - we know for certain that there is a Mafia A leader and Soleron made a lot of posts while he was alive, and right now I trust arguments based on evidence like that more than just incidents of bad playing.

sabby_17:

So apart from that, I haven't really done anything scummy. As for Soleron, don't any of you think he posted those comments because of the attention some of the players had attracted? Like when Supermario wa the prime suspect due to his day one "no vote" and his ordinary defence? The same applies to Vetteman, Godofwar, and Silver_tiger (for lurking if I remember correctly).

Yes I do think Soleron made those comments based on the amount of attention attracted by players, BUT I don't see why he would encourage suspicion against players on his own team. This is why I think they are indications that these players are not part of the Mafia A team, and they help in searching for who is.



Around the Network

But there are 12 players alive still, no? So, 7 to lynch?




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

trangentspree said:

Okay, to clarify.

I haven't been trying to make a case for thinking that supermario, Vetteman or anybody else definitely isn't scum. I'm just making a case for who I think the Mafia A leader might be, because all the bad playing in this game recently has made it difficult to determine people's alignments from their behaviour alone. Vetteman made those ridiculously feeble bandwagons, and supermario has been defiantly erratic so much so that I'm left wondering if he's even trying to play the game at all. And they aren't the only ones either (silver-tiger being another recent example,) just perhaps the worst ones.

Honestly I'm at a loss in as far as determining who to vote for based on behaviour because we could vote for quite a few people right now. That's why I decided to try and look at things from another perspective - we know for certain that there is a Mafia A leader and Soleron made a lot of posts while he was alive, and right now I trust arguments based on evidence like that more than just incidents of bad playing.

sabby_17:

So apart from that, I haven't really done anything scummy. As for Soleron, don't any of you think he posted those comments because of the attention some of the players had attracted? Like when Supermario wa the prime suspect due to his day one "no vote" and his ordinary defence? The same applies to Vetteman, Godofwar, and Silver_tiger (for lurking if I remember correctly).

Yes I do think Soleron made those comments based on the amount of attention attracted by players, BUT I don't see why he would encourage suspicion against players on his own team. This is why I think they are indications that these players are not part of the Mafia A team, and they help in searching for who is.


Yes, that makes sense. But don't forget that Mafia do tend to "pretend" to suspect their own players to make themselves seem pro-town. And Soleron is a player who posts findings of almost everything. Plus, if he missed out a player or two, that would make him look suspicious. You have to also ask your self why he was "unsure" if I was pro-town or scum (as indicated by his list of scum, pro-town and not sure). Was it possibly because I hadn't done anything stupid unlike Supermario  or lurking?




sabby_e17 said:

I hadn't done anything stupid unlike Supermario  or lurking?


Well maybe not back then. But, you were lurking for a pretty long time, long enough to make me forget you were even in this game. And none of my actions were stupid, they were all done for a reason.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

supermario128 said:
sabby_e17 said:

I hadn't done anything stupid unlike Supermario  or lurking?


Well maybe not back then. But, you were lurking for a pretty long time, long enough to make me forget you were even in this game. And none of my actions were stupid, they were all done for a reason.


If I remember correctly, I had many more posts than you, Vetteman, and quite a few other posters. But no one forgot that you and Vetteman were in the game. So you forgetting that I was in the game is your problem.




Around the Network
sabby_e17 said:


If I remember correctly, I had many more posts than you, Vetteman, and quite a few other posters. But no one forgot that you and Vetteman were in the game. So you forgetting that I was in the game is your problem.


I was gone for a 4 day vacation, I don't think you were. Me forgetting about you until now shows you are trying to lay low. I think you have the highest chance at being scum right now, in my opinion.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

supermario128 said:
sabby_e17 said:


If I remember correctly, I had many more posts than you, Vetteman, and quite a few other posters. But no one forgot that you and Vetteman were in the game. So you forgetting that I was in the game is your problem.


I was gone for a 4 day vacation, I don't think you were. Me forgetting about you until now shows you are trying to lay low. I think you have the highest chance at being scum right now, in my opinion.


Me looking back at what you did found your defensive statements crap. But me thought you was still innocent. Then me saw you and Vetteman, the two major previous suspects bandwagon on me instantly without me defending my self. Me then thought you trying to save your ass by bandwagoning over me. Me still unsure wether you is criminal because you is daft anyway but who else is there (apart from me and possibly Nikells)?????

And I did say that I have been very busy and only have chance at 8-10pm to post whatever I want.




Nikells said:
trangentspree said:

People who I think or know are Town: tanstalas, dsister, stefl, Gnizmo (that dejected tone has to be real), Nikells (don't know why really, just an impression), theRepublic (convincing lines of argument.)

He's put me in a list with the majority of the confirmed/dead pro-town players.

Also: I have something I want to ask j0.


Yes? 



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

c03n3nj0 said:
Nikells said:
He's put me in a list with the majority of the confirmed/dead pro-town players.

Also: I have something I want to ask j0.

Yes? 

Are you the serial killer? Be honest.



sabby_e17 said:
supermario128 said:
sabby_e17 said:


If I remember correctly, I had many more posts than you, Vetteman, and quite a few other posters. But no one forgot that you and Vetteman were in the game. So you forgetting that I was in the game is your problem.


I was gone for a 4 day vacation, I don't think you were. Me forgetting about you until now shows you are trying to lay low. I think you have the highest chance at being scum right now, in my opinion.


Me looking back at what you did found your defensive statements crap. But me thought you was still innocent. Then me saw you and Vetteman, the two major previous suspects bandwagon on me instantly without me defending my self. Me then thought you trying to save your ass by bandwagoning over me. Me still unsure wether you is criminal because you is daft anyway but who else is there (apart from me and possibly Nikells)?????

Dude aren't you from the UK? what kind of gramar is that? (yes that was off topic... but that was hard to read)



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO