Also, do you really think a mafia member would do something as stupid as I did and draw all that attention to them?

That is why I am not sure about voting for you, but on the other hand this could just be a trick to look like innocent. And I even withdraw my vote in order to get him talking, he might have unveiled one other mafia involuntarily but you had to hammervote him...

So first off:

Everyone should be able to defend themselves...even if they are proven to be scum!

Second:

He might have made a fatal mistake unveiling his partner/s to us... maybe we would be rid of Mafia B by tonight! Which would mean one night kill less.

It's not like we suspect you for the vote, but rather how you voted. Transgentspree clearly said NO MORE VOTES, he even bolded it, so you couldn't miss mit. We were still in  the discussion, RCT didn't even had the chance to defend himself. But then you hammered it with your vote.

The town has to work together to win.. We don't need people going roque and doing it all by themself.

HAHAHAAAA ! How could I have missed this - blatantly obvious Johnny Cage reference/hint

On second thought, no....

SnakeEyez, the deputy was lynched and TheRepublic's death was by the hands of (presumably) the Serial Killer.

Attention To ALL PLAYERS

Hephaestos will be replacing hatmoza, please show him some MK...HOSPITALITY!!

What I Think of Everybody Who are Playing !

C03n3nj0

He hasn’t posted anything for me to be suspicious of…It seems he is playing his cards close to his chest…he is either a vanilla townie like yours truly, or has a very important role may it be pro-town or anti-town….

Noteworthy posts –

“Eh, actually, when hatmoza explained why khuutra was asking for protection from the doc (I'm pretty sure this happened in a post somewhere), that's about the easiest way to back up your mafia buddy without bring too much suspicion to yourself. 

Look at it this way: someone comes up saying he needs protection 'cause he's good, then the next person says "yeah! This guy has a point" it's essentially pushing the doc further to protect khuutra. 

It was just a thought I was having actually, so I wouldn't mind it because this sounds too conspiracy-ish.”

If this is as he assumed, hatmoza would be anti-town, that may hold some truth as he might be trying to mislead the town into thinking stefl is mafia (although that is not impossible). But then again, he is asking to be replaced, but does that necessarily mean he is a good guy ?

“No.

Falcon always, like literally always lurks whether he's pro or anti-town. Also he hasn't been online. 

So Falcon could either be modkilled, or lynched for inactivity, which I don't necessarily recommend unless we're in a worse position.”

This has been spot on ! Falcon was a townie ! We proceeded to lynch someone else on Day 2 though that someone shouldn’t have been SnakeEyez.

3ever’s vibe – Pro-Town

Dsister44

Tough one. He is by far the most active player in the game (therefore I’m not even gonna bother with “note-worthy posts”. I was leaning towards him being anti-town for his random voting and posts which I found to be odd (partly because I’ve never played mafia with him). Then stefl said that he was innocent, but with controversy on whether stefl is mafia or not, it is possible that he is, indeed, anti-town.

Noteworthy posts (about him, but not by him) –

“The Ability used by Dsis made him look pretty much innocent, though I said in my first post about him that he "might have a important role for the town", later on to go into no risks I claimed I am sure that he is town (after being asked by someone... i don't remember exactly who it was)” – Stefl1504

Yeah, its Stefl again…but we’ve got nothing on him.

3ever’s vibe – MY BRAIN !!!!! IT HURTZ….

Hatmoza

So, he is asking to be replaced, but is he trying to confuse the town with bringing forth the possibility of stefl being mafia as his anti-town swan song (did that make sense ?) or is he genuinely trying to leave the game with a bang by trying to make us think of something we haven’t already ?

Noteworthy posts –

“ skimmed through the game quickly and let me say this, I highly believe Stefl is a mafia cop [EDIT* which can explain how quickly the good cops themselves were discovered so quickly]. We have the cop and sub-cop both dead and they're both town, so even though stefl may be telling the truth about whats-his-face being scum, he could easily be scum himself trying to get the towns trust.”

It doesn’t explain why the cops were “found” easily. One was lynched and the other was killed by “Other” means which do not include mafia.

“As for Stefl, unless there's sanity role cops, I'm 100% sure he's scum. I do not believe that there were 2 cops in the game and a deputy. That's unrealistic.”

The 100% sure of him being scum is an over-exaggerated comment me thinks. Looks like he is gonna be replaced soon anyway.

“HoS anyone who suggested a random number of mafia players in a group”

Very True.

3ever’s vibe – Pro-town…ish

Nikells

After posting quite a bit (and sharing my suspicion on Khuutra who asked to be protected, day freaking 1), he hasn’t been all that active lately. And he seems to have popped up for quite a few posts after he was voted to be lynched by Trangentspree. This points to him being scummish as the last time he was semi-lurking, he turned out to be scum and started posting a lot once votes were coming in his direction. So to prevent the same thing from happening again, he decided to take a more active approach to the game ?

3ever’s vibe – Anti-town…ish

Noname2200

Another big contributor to the game, whom I initially thought had no way of being mafia, but now….I’m not too sure. With assumptions on the number of mafia, and trying to appear confused about the colours in the OP. I genuinely think he might be the serial killer. :O

I think he is trying to slip under the radar.

Noteworthy posts –

“So red is one type of murder, and blue is another type of murder.  Soleron, a mafia, got killed by a bomb, but he's blue rather than red, and he presumably killed tanstalas, who is also blue.  The two people killed on Day One are red, we know they were both mafia, and we know that they killed each other.

Either I'm missing something, or the colors don't mean as much as I thought.”

“If stefl was a mafia cop, he'd be the last member of mafia A, unless we assume four-member mafias.”

Colour confusion “plus” numbers FTW ! (NOT)

3ever’s vibe – Anti-town (Can’t believe I typed that)

Sabby_e17

This guy happens to be very confused at different parts of the game. Like recently. So I may have over-reacted a bit in voting for him.

Unvote : Sabby_e17

But then again, this strikes me as suspicious –

“But I thought that it was possible for there to be more than one cop (I've played in games where there are multiple cops). I'm not sure if we still do that because I haven't played in the past games for like 3 months.”

Why didn’t he mention this in his original post of claiming that he believes that stefl would be innocent ?

Either way, 3ever’s vibe – pro-town…ish

Silver-Tiger

Very interesting.

Post #1 – Off-topic stuff and announcement of his arrival

Post #2 – Votes “No Lynch” and comments on Hephaestos’ absence (This Post was edited.)

Post #3 – “Why are you suspecting me so much? I'm just not the type of person who writes endless comments about people lurking around. I comment when I think it's neccessary. Look at my post count. Every other active member would have 1000 posts already by that time already.”  (This was edited too).

Post #4 – Says that 2 mafia scum have died on day one and its not bad at all.

Post #5 – FoS’s dsister for his random accusations of people.

Post #6 – Agrees that he doesn’t have much to add to the discussion by quoting my post. I said that because I don’t have any night actions since I’m a vanilla townie. Did silver-tiger seize the opportunity to find a good excuse to get away with posting not so much ?

Post #7 – Questions stefl about what he wants to hear from him.

Post #8 – Doesn’t know what question dsister asked him.

Post #9 – Answers to dsister

Post #10 –  Mentions that bandwagoning is usually a bad idea and he is going with it because he believes someone has to be lynched on day 2 as day 1 was a no lynch. Says that the town has no leads and mentions that both kills on night 1 were by the mafia.

Also mentions that if someone turns up dead after he accuses somebody, the person who was accused should be looked at with caution.

Post #11 – Responds to republic’s comment on his “the accused looks guilty” theory.

Post #12 – Wonders whether there are other factions who aren’t mafia in addition to the SK as the OP lists the Blue kills as “Other”.

Post #13 – Says that nen would have wrote “SK” in the OP instead of others.

Post #14 – Says he didn’t notice that theRepublic was killed like a few others hadn’t.

Post #15 – Votes for RCT, says that he suspected him and says we should concentrate on vetteman next.

Post #16 – Replies to RCT’s claim for not being able to defend himself with “It doesn’t matter, you were scum anyway”

Post #17 –

“FoS: Nikells

Come to think of it, we really haven't heard of him much. Last time he was so quiet he turned out to be scum. I won't vote for him now, though, since I have no solid evidence (yet).

Vote: Vetteman

But I will vote for Vetteman, just reread Noname2200's post about him, you know why I vote for him. My Vote is open for discussion, though, so if you convince me that you are innocent, I will unvote, Vetteman. See it more as a chance to get you taking rather than a vote.

And lastly:

HoS: Supermario128

He was in the talks at the beginning of the game for Voting "No lynch" before the discussion really started (Probably to make himself look unsuspicous.) And now, he hammered RCTjunkie when we were still in discussion and RCT did't even had a chance to defend himself.

Yeah I know I'm throwing out a lot of suspicions, but I think I'm really starting to get in the game. XD”

Post #18 - Brings up the blue kill again. This time in response to noname

Post #19 – Mentions about the colour thing…again

Post #20 – Talks about SM128’s hammervote.

As you can see he has kept a low profile, but toward the final few posts, especially #17, makes me believe,

3ever’s vibe – pro-town..ish

Stefl1504

I don’t know what to say, other than the fact that he might be a mafia cop OR an insane cop.

Insane cop because, mafia leaders…or godfathers, appear innocent in cop investigations, yet RCT was found guilty by him..(innocent cop always gets opposite investigation resuts…) This would mean dsister is anti-town.

But when Bus-Drivers jump into the equation, this becomes very complicated.

3ever’s vibe – MY BRAIN !!!!! IT HURTZ….

Supermario128

Anyone who doesn’t think he is scum needs to be sent into the path of a firing squad.

Voting No Lynch before the game got started properly, then being M.I.A. and returning to lynch another lurker (who happened to be innocent), hammervoting RCT when people have instructed others not to vote anymore and acting pretty weird all the way through.

3ever’s vibe – GUILTY GUILTY GUILTY !!!!!!

TrangentSpree

Very interesting again. Was active on day one and goes missing, blaming a head ache and returns to FoS me and SnakeEyez

“f I were to take a guess at who I suspected were most likely to be scum right now, my answer would be either god_of_war or snake-eyez.”

Sure, it could be what he genuinely thought from a pro-town perspective, I find it odd that his suspects were both pro-town.

Then he makes a few posts about past events as he is reading through the thread…. Its too unclear to tell but,

3ever’s vibe – pro-town..

Vetteman94

Even though there is no concrete proof, I assume not many think Vetteman is pro-town either.

3ever’s vibe – Anti-town

You voted for both SM128 and Vetteman... I assume you wanted to vote for SM128 since it was the last vote in your text...

silver-tiger voted vetteman....I voted SM128....I'd edit the bold part out of silver's post now.

And stefl.....what exactly is your role dude ? I know you ain't a cop, but how would you describe your role in your words ?

Currently reading the thread, i'm at page 18/32.. though I should probably skip to the long posts as you guys seem to love doing a summary of the posts =)

That FF/Kut double kill was fun though!

PS: Thanks Hatmoza for being serious on your exams!