By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 18 Game Thread

So red is one type of murder, and blue is another type of murder.  Soleron, a mafia, got killed by a bomb, but he's blue rather than red, and he presumably killed tanstalas, who is also blue.  The two people killed on Day One are red, we know they were both mafia, and we know that they killed each other.

Either I'm missing something, or the colors don't mean as much as I thought.



Around the Network
noname2200 said:

So red is one type of murder, and blue is another type of murder.  Soleron, a mafia, got killed by a bomb, but he's blue rather than red, and he presumably killed tanstalas, who is also blue.  The two people killed on Day One are red, we know they were both mafia, and we know that they killed each other.

Either I'm missing something, or the colors don't mean as much as I thought.


I assume blue kill means some kind of special death, like bomb death, people's abilitys. Red kill probably means the "normal" kill of a mafia.



updated: 14.01.2012

playing right now: Xenoblade Chronicles

Hype-o-meter, from least to most hyped:  the Last Story, Twisted Metal, Mass Effect 3, Final Fantasy XIII-2, Final Fantasy Versus XIII, Playstation ViTA

bet with Mordred11 that Rage will look better on Xbox 360.

Silver-Tiger said:


I assume blue kill means some kind of special death, like bomb death, people's abilitys. Red kill probably means the "normal" kill of a mafia.


That would make sense, especially if we assume that tanstalas "killed himself" rather than got killed by Soleron.



noname2200 said:

So red is one type of murder, and blue is another type of murder.  Soleron, a mafia, got killed by a bomb, but he's blue rather than red, and he presumably killed tanstalas, who is also blue.  The two people killed on Day One are red, we know they were both mafia, and we know that they killed each other.

Either I'm missing something, or the colors don't mean as much as I thought.

Red - Mafia kills. It can be mafia A or mafia B.

Blue - All other types of night kills - Serial Killer, Bomb.

Tanstalas is pretty much a suicide bomb. Soleron didn't kill Tanstalas, he got killed by Tanstalas' blast, and Tanstalas died too.

Oh and hatmoza's theory of Stefl being a mafia cop makes sense.....so be vary of him....and dsister (who was cleared by stefl).

Vote : SM128

(its blatantly obvious that SM128 is scum...his behaviour is crazy to say the least...explain yourself dude !)



GodOfWar_3ever said:

Oh and hatmoza's theory of Stefl being a mafia cop makes sense.....so be vary of him....and dsister (who was cleared by stefl).

Vote : SM128

(its blatantly obvious that SM128 is scum...his behaviour is crazy to say the least...explain yourself dude !)

If stefl was a mafia cop, he'd be the last member of mafia A, unless we assume four-member mafias.  In that case,
why would he choose to shield dsister, who's presumably not on either mafia?  Admittedly, it was odd how quickly and ineptly he showed his cards that day, but that doesn't mean he's mafia.



Around the Network

noname2200 said:

If stefl was a mafia cop, he'd be the last member of mafia A, unless we assume four-member mafias.  In that case, 

why would he choose to shield dsister, who's presumably not on either mafia?  Admittedly, it was odd how quickly and ineptly he showed his cards that day, but that doesn't mean he's mafia.

We don't know how many mafia are there for sure anyway...its all assumptions...just remember to take what stefl says with a grain of salt.



Silver-Tiger said:

Vote: Vetteman

But I will vote for Vetteman, just reread Noname2200's post about him, you know why I vote for him. My Vote is open for discussion, though, so if you convince me that you are innocent, I will unvote, Vetteman. See it more as a chance to get you taking rather than a vote.

Which part of noname's post that brought on this vote,  there is alot of nonsense in there and I want to know which part I am to address.  I am assuming its not the part I already commented on otherwise how much more can I make the situation clear.  I never lied about the situation,  just others looking to twist the situation to their benefit. 

Also If i havent made myself clear as of yet,  what else would I possibly be able to do to convince you that I am innocent?  Would a character and a role claim help?  That would obviously spell doom for me though so I am reluctent to do that. 



Why am I not replaced yet >_<

if this game is anything like the previous (my game) 4 mafia per team is not out of the  question, heck this game is bigger so I wouldn't be surprised if there were 5 players per mafia group.

As for Stefl, unless there's sanity role cops, I'm 100% sure he's scum. I do not believe that there were 2 cops in the game and a deputy. That's unrealistic. noname, you've been a great contributor to the game (well at least from what I remember a few days ago) but you diverting attention away from stefl and the mafia cop scenerio is making me want to do a double lynch tonight on the both of you tonight.

I believe the town is in real deep shit, especially if we're looking at 2-3 kills a night. We're getting pretty lucky , but we can't rely  on lucky night actions to make this town win.

I want to lynch SMB but something deep down inside me tells me it's the wrong move.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

because I can't promise I'll be online anytime soon.

Vote: Stefl

I just feel it.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

hatmoza said:

Why am I not replaced yet >_<

if this game is anything like the previous (my game) 4 mafia per team is not out of the  question, heck this game is bigger so I wouldn't be surprised if there were 5 players per mafia group.

As for Stefl, unless there's sanity role cops, I'm 100% sure he's scum. I do not believe that there were 2 cops in the game and a deputy. That's unrealistic. noname, you've been a great contributor to the game (well at least from what I remember a few days ago) but you diverting attention away from stefl and the mafia cop scenerio is making me want to do a double lynch tonight on the both of you tonight.

I believe the town is in real deep shit, especially if we're looking at 2-3 kills a night. We're getting pretty lucky , but we can't rely  on lucky night actions to make this town win.

I want to lynch SMB but something deep down inside me tells me it's the wrong move.

Just remembered something vital
Here's something to think about fellow towns whoever the fuck you are. The previous game which I hosted, I believe (IIRC) that it was the mafia scum who were trying to convince others that the number of mafia players in a group was smaller than what it actually was.

HoS anyone who suggested a random number of mafia players in a group



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson