I don't want him posting because it puts him into the game. He should not influence the game at all. Having him post about any error puts him in a position to control the outcome. As it stands it can be seen as one of the two of us lying. If hatmoza were to post confirming or denying it his word would influence the reactions of everyone to that essential split. As it stands even though I mentioned it the worth of the accusation is determined only by a person's ability to believe me. Make sense in a crazy way at least.

I say again, you were not home night 1. I don't know what all you were doing, or why you were gone. I know you were gone. I asked hatmoza to confirm, and he confirmed what I thought was the right one. Your recent claim to have a one off action is an interesting one. I don't know why you want to keep it hidden, but I am unwilling to trust you at this point without a lot of evidence to back it up. I don't know whether or not you would lie, but I am pretty certain that my ability wouldn't. I have seen it work perfectly at least one other time, so you would need a strong case to make me believe it didn't work the first time.

Ok well sorry j0 but you should have pressed for a vote sooner... it ain't your birthday no more :p

i'll put back my vote untill there is a massive different voting (fufinu?).

There are interesting discutions going on though.

Vote: j0

Bolded: That's why I would not mind him having do this. I for one, have nothing to hide in this situation.

Given I know I was not out day 1, and you are still claiming otherwise, it is not you whom I should convince but the other participants. I believe that you are acting in a very inconsistent manner. You have been baiting to query what others have been up to throughout the thread. You did not point fingers at a person at a time. Will try and go through the posts, but I believe that you poached two persons on the second day as well as multiple others on the following.

Will try and go through to prove this point.

I did push for two people on the second day. SnakeEyez posted on Night 1 about his night action. I kept up with that too. Check the top of page 3 (100 posts per page) to see where he asks about it, I think. There is no ability needed there. Everyone can see it. Final-fan even responded to it. You, and everyone else are welcome to search through this thread. Everything I have said has been confirmed, plus or minus my theories to explain the results I got. I know my ability, and I know it works.

Also, having something to hide is not the reason to keep hatmoza out of this. He is not playing this game though. We are. Having him post makes him a player and he has too much information to be a player. You give 3 scenarios that explain this situation away perfectly. What if the answer is 3? Hatmoza could confirm it in one post and give out completely reliable information that is impossible for a player to get. That throws the whole dynamic off, and wrecks the game.

This was after night 2 ... and shortly after what do we get?

(coming in next post)

Mind explaining who you investigated on both days? Unless you can hit 2 per night all this makes no sense.

@Gnizmo: Situation 3 would not ruin the dynamics of the game. It would actually help sort it out.

The multiple investigations seem to have happened on night 2. I am happy about the Snake eyez explanation.

Sigh. I was hoping to avoid delving too deep into this one, but you leave me no choice. I target one person per night. I see if they are home, and who else might be there. You were not home. Godofwar was, and others showed up to the party.

You keep evading though. You were not home night 1. You offer no explanation for why, and continue to attack someone proven innocent. I can't see anything changing my vote at the moment. Hopefully others follow suit.

Sorting it out is the game.

gnizmo, how many people can you check and see whether they were home or not in a night ?  And whom did you investigate ?