Is there any discernible difference between the Xbox 360 and Ps3 versions?

I guess that PS3 has exclusive content.

visual comparison from a reasonable sounding person on Gaf:


"What we know:

Xbox 360 version runs at 720p with 2XAA according to "pro" pixel counter MazingerDUDE.

What we suspect:

PS3 version is most likely sub hd. Has been speculated for months and was the same for GTAIV and Midnight club.

A resolution of 640p (which is not too far away from 720p) seems likely at the moment.

MazingerDUDE had the following to say, based off some bad quality off screen grabs:

"I'd need direct grabs for some accurate analysis, but taking a possibility of overscan into account, the game probably runs at the same res as GTA4 (640P)."


What we don't know:

Framerate on both versions
GTAIV initially ran about 10% better on Xbox 360. Episodes from Liberty City gave the PS3 engine a boost and improved the framerate up to par to the 360 version. Midnight Club sports a higher framerate on the PS3 (source: Digital Foundry)
Impressions so far suggest a better frame rate for the 360 version.

Dithering on Xbox 360
GTAIV on Xbox 360 had heavy problems with dithered textures and shadows, decreasing the overall image quality greatly. This led to people preferring the PS3 version, even though it was inferior from a pure technical point of view. (720p 2XAA vs. 640p with blur filter)
(Digital Foundry, Quaz51 and IGN are prominent sources)

Update: Judging from the footage we've seen so far, the shadowing issue has been greatly improved, if not resolved. The dithering issue still seems to be visible on trees, marston's beard in a different screenshot, etc. though.

A direct feed comparison with the PS3 version is necessary.

PS3 Anti Aliasing
The original GTA IV PS3 had no AA, just a blur filter. Selective Quincunx AA has been added to the engine with the release of the DLC packs. Midnight Club implies Quincunx AA as well. An absence of any form of AA in RdR would be a disappointment.

Tearing
PS3 GTAIV is v-locked, 360 version had very slight tearing. From impressions so far, the same could be the case for RDR.

Pop in
GTAIV streaming was pretty identical on both consoles"

So it looks like visuals lean towards 360, and then there's some kind of exclusive DLC for PS3 but I don't know what it is.

What content?

Thanks for that.  That was a fair bit of effort.

Sounds like I'll try and find out what this exclusive content is.  If it's meaningful I'll get the PS3 version, if it's not, the Xbox 360 version

Not so much... I read about some clothes, weapons and a hideout.

Hmm.  They don't seem to know what it is.

I'll wait a couple of days.

Cheers CGI

This happens every time a multi-plat gets released. How about you buy it on the system you own? If you own both then buy for either its a win-win. If there are huge issues (i.e. tearing, frame rate) between versions they are usually highly documented in reviews and would have been brought up by now.

just thought i'd post this i cannot see any framerate problems in this ps3 footage:):)

Red Dead Redemption: 10 Minutes PS3 Gameplay Footage

Videogameszone published a new video showing ten minutes of Red Dead Redemption (PS3 version) gameplay footage. Hint: Click on "HD" to watch the video in high definition. (PS3, Red Dead Redemption)

Watch video >>     Discuss (34)

what do you think?? i think it looks pretty good if you ask me:):)

It seems pretty clear.

Xbox 360 has a slight visual edge, but the PS3 has exclusive content.  If this hideout is a shack in the desert I'll get the Xbox 360 version.

If it's more substantial, PS3.