I'm sorry but i wouldnt come close to calling any of those options the best game of all time, solely because a game needs to have massive staying power to gain the title, and all those on your list have been out for two years tops.

there should have been an other option >_

I don't think any of those games deserve the title. I would have to give it to Shadow of the Colossus for me personally.

NONE OF THEM. This's the game you're looking for:

In 100 years our succesors'll be playing some kind of Tetris, Do you really think that somebody is going to remember Halo, MGS, etc. by that time?

Most of the games that made a decent jump from 2D to 3D should get that title IMO. Most have more content than their 2D counterparts too.

none of the above

As this is the second dang thread in like a two minutes period to sucker me in by a generic title to be followed up with a very specific list I feel the need to say this: I would really appreciate titles that let me know that what a thread is about before i click it.

If you are asking for best games of all time, then you list is not even really in my top 10.

Metroid Prime.

Chrono Trigger

Damn it too much new garbage up there =_=