2 things. 

1. First off I don't really want it to make it sound like I am trying to defend him or anything but I am willing(at this point) to write it off as him just being a newb.

2. You might want to add a quote box to where you quoted him. It looks like you voted for Falcon 

To be fair I did use quotation marks, but I should have unbolded it.

That may be a valid defense but I want him to come in and explain it himself, and maybe then I'll believe him. I'm not going to just preemptively give him a pass considering the amount of odd stuff he's done.

theRepublic: We've had this conversation before but in short: You made some good points about myslynch vs mafia kill and I agree with most of your conclusions EXCEPT for the first day because lynching a random player will provide little valuable information on where the rest of the town stands and that loosing a townie is too high of a price for inconclusive information.

While I am still suspicious of theRepublic, him and Final-Fan bring up good points about Stefl1504. He has moved up to number 1 on my suspect list. I would like to here an explanation on these accusations.

FoS: Stefl1504

Maybe it was the stuff about hating Nintendo?

I greatly admire him.

Right then, my thoughts on night 1.
Suspects:

Stefl1504
I'm willing to cut stefl some slack because its his first game. But the evidence is really stacking up against him now.

- Voted to lynch someone for a very unconvincing reason and then changing that reason when questioned about it.
- Changing his vote to no lynch to end the day quickly.

I'd vote for Stefl now: but he almost seems too easy of a target. Surely if he had mafia brothers they'd be helping him out and he wouldn't be making himself look so completely bloodthirsty?

FOS: Stefl1504

Unless we can find a more guilty suspect to lynch or stefl can come up with a compelling reason to explain why he's been so hungry for blood this past day I'm going to vote for him.


dsister44
I'm becoming more suspicious of dsister. Perhaps he's just being nice to the new player but it really does seem like hes going above and beyond when it comes to defending Stefl. He also pushed to end the day. As much as ignoring Trangent's pompous demands is tempting, in this case he did have a point.

If Stefl is lynched today and turns up guilty I'd heartily recommend lynching dsister next.

I'd also like to hear something from the following people as my lurker sense is starting to tingle:
 falcon, SciFiBoy, KingFate, dtewi

I think you mean Day One, unless this is some sort of slip up.  

I agree about the lurkers.

@Nikells: I agree about your lurker list except for the fact that dtewi was replaced by Vetteman94. You should always pay attention to things like that, they say not paying attention is a scum tell.

Ah yes, sorry: I was using the list of players from the first page as reference for who i hadn't seen speak for a while.
Obviously scratch the part about dtewi as Vetteman has posted plenty lately.

I didn't realise the mafia couldn't talk to each other during the day: this pretty much kills my doubts about lynching Stefl.
I'm not going to vote for him before everybody has had their say though. 

@theRepublic: I did mean night 1: these are my opinions now that I've seen what's happened during the night. I was going to mention that hopefully someone (a doctor) has successfully blocked a night kill and now has fairly solid evidence that whoever was targeted is pro-town.
Obviously I don't expect the doctor to say anything: but its an advantage that even a single person has information that could prevent a miss-lynch.