If some game is very good,there must be a lot of great reviews or online HD videos nowadays.

I don't know where's your doubt come from,but why not try to read or watch it instead of posting a "Is xxx really that good" thread???

If you don't trust anyone,then go see for yourself.

So every time K-mart shits on you,you run for Wal-Mart???What a weird guy.

If your whining about that GOW thread then you should just say so.....is it really hard to say that?

Ive never been soo lost reading an op like I have today

you are talking about believers of an ancient religious prophecy or something?

I typed threads.

WHAT  DOES THAT EVEN MEAN???!??

I am soo lost and am never coming back to this mess of a thread...

means "Is XXX that great" kind of threads.

lol ok guys let's try and stay on topic since he clarified :D but damn man the initial post is confusing as hell

as for your questions : reviews = an opinion of one or two people....comments on youtube videos etc are most of the time comments by fanboys....

so why ask here in a community dedicated to gaming? simple..cuz they trust their views more..sure there are some who would comment on how good or bad a game is even without playing it(and in some cases not even owning that particular console or even used it before) BUT overall you would wanna hear what your fellow gamers thought of it...nothing more nothing less

I think I understand.
He's saying people who write a threat Is (insert game of choice here) good? already don't trust people since there are many reviews for the game out there. So why bother coming here to ask people?

My answer. Some people here trust other members opinions more than a reviewer they can't have a dialog with. It can be a conversation instead of just reading someones review or watching a video. When you know other members opinions on several things and why they feel that way you can get a better sense of where their opinion comes from. While most here wouldn't go out looking to see how (insert specific reviewer here) feels about every game they have reviewed and why? It would be like asking a few friends who have similar tastes instead of just looking at reviews.

What he was actually saying (not really asking) was: if a lot of people say about a certain game (game xxx) that it is great, people ("doubters") should not create threads titled "is game xxx any good" because already a lot of people posted that the game was great.

I don't agree , but I'm pretty sure that's what he meant.