By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 15A - Game Thread - Vanilla Round

dtewi on 24 March 2010
GodOfWar_3ever said:

 

Me OK..lets clear some shit up.
After Vetteman voted no lynch, I quoted him and said "OK then, : No Lynch". In his post he mentioned "us townies", suggesting that he is a townie...Since I'm new to mafia, I quickly edited my post thinking that he is falsely interpreting himself as a townie to make another townie slip up.
Afterwards I realized that if he WAS mafia, he would know who is a townie and who is not. So it was all a newb disaster by me.
Then I checked what everyone voted on day 1

OK..lets clear some shit up. I changed my vote above from theRepublic to dtewi (is that allowed ? please give me one more chance since I'm a first timer )

After Vetteman94 voted no lynch, I quoted him and said "OK then, : No Lynch". In his post he mentioned "us townies", suggesting that he is a townie...Since I'm new to mafia, I quickly edited my post thinking that he is falsely interpreting himself as a townie to make another townie slip up.

Afterwards I realized that if he WAS mafia, he would know who is a townie and who is not. So it was all a newb disaster by me.

Then I checked what everyone voted on day 1

No lynch voters

  • ArkZero
  • dtewi
  • KingFate
  • SciFiBoy
  • Vetteman94
I think its safe to assume that these guys (or majority of them anyway) are probably townies.
People who didn't vote
  • Me (because I wasn't online)
  • insomniac17
  • Nikells
  • theRepublic
So, I know I'm not mafia, and Nikells isn't either.
That leaves 7 people with the possibility of being mafia. Out of those 7, insomniac17 and theRepublic didn't vote.
I'm convinced that Vetteman94 isn't mafia judging by his first game related post. If he is, then he is EVIL. But its most likely he isn't because there is no way someone who is mafia would pretend that he is a townie like THAT. Which leads me to suspect dtewi (I will get to this later in the post).
People who were interested in my edit who suspect me of being mafia are obviously townies, if they are mafia, they would know I'm one of them. So that eradicates the possibility of SciFiBoy, KingFate and probably even theRepublic (sorry dude, I wanted to spice things up) being mafia.
Mafia suspects 
ArkZero -
He only voted no lynch because he feels the chance of a lynch happening is unlikely. (Mafia probability - 65%)
dtewi -
calling out for a cop, as a frequent player of the game he was not bothered about my edit...Voting No lynch for the sake of reverse psychology me thinks...
"Oh my god, it took half a page for Night 1 to start." - Doesn't this mean he was anxiously waiting for night 1 to arrive so he can kill Nikells who had made some brilliant observations ?
(Mafia probability - 80%)
insomniac17 -
Also not bothered by my edit, didn't vote. (Mafia probability - 55%)
theRepublic -
Didn't vote, didn't give away much at all in his posts. (Mafia probability - 55%)
Now lynch dtewi before the mafia kill me too !

 


OK, this post bugs me. He votes for me because of my surprise at how night started so quickly (which I can forgive as he wouldn't know other first days have taken upwards of hundreds of posts) but then he votes for me BECAUSE I didn't suspect him. This may be newbie mistakes, but I don't think so.

Kimi wa ne tashika ni ano toki watashi no soba ni ita

Itsudatte itsudatte itsudatte

Sugu yoko de waratteita

Nakushitemo torimodosu kimi wo

I will never leave you

Around the Network
dtewi on 24 March 2010

Since editting is not allowed, allow me to expand on my thoughts.

God of war proceeds to say that I voted no lynch because of reverse psychology (that's pretty stupid since there would be NO purpose of it). Then he says four people have more than half a chance of being mafia. Really, that makes no sense. If there are only two or three, then there's no way all of them could be likely of being mafia.

He also says Nikells made some brilliant observations (they were OK, but nothing to be amazed at). I think god of war wanted Nikells dead because of what he saw. And he proceeded to vote Vetteman after he said he didn't think he was mafia at all.

Again, I might chalk this up to inexperience, but I would like you, GOD OF WAR, to explain why you thought Nikells made very good observations and the vote for vetteman.

As of now. Vote: God of war



Kimi wa ne tashika ni ano toki watashi no soba ni ita

Itsudatte itsudatte itsudatte

Sugu yoko de waratteita

Nakushitemo torimodosu kimi wo

I will never leave you

dtewi on 24 March 2010

OK, sorry for triple post.

Bah, godofwar didn't vote vetterman. That thing looks really confusing zexen. I can't tell whos' getting voted for who's voting.



Kimi wa ne tashika ni ano toki watashi no soba ni ita

Itsudatte itsudatte itsudatte

Sugu yoko de waratteita

Nakushitemo torimodosu kimi wo

I will never leave you

insomniac17 on 24 March 2010
dtewi said:
OK, sorry for triple post.

Bah, godofwar didn't vote vetterman. That thing looks really confusing zexen. I can't tell whos' getting voted for who's voting.

Oops. I was going by that chart too. It looks like his last vote was for you.

insomniac17 said:

Does this seem like an overreaction to anyone else? You have one vote for you. You voted for Vetteman. Right now, you're a suspect, but you're not in immediate danger of being lynched by any means.

@SciFi, I agree. I would also like to hear an explanation from ArkZero.

Should be dtewi.



Latest News/Discussion for Star Wars: Rebels and Star Wars: The Clone Wars!


KingFate on 24 March 2010

GoW you gotta stop editing posts man, the fact that you continued to do it AFTER you were told not to, just seems to make you seem REALLY scumy. Also the gut reactions aren't exactly the best way to go about lynching people. You need to give a reasonable reason for lynching someone.



PSN ID: KingFate_

Around the Network
ArkZero on 24 March 2010
SciFiBoy said:

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3271912&page=3&postnum=6

not been around for ages...returns purely to bandwagon FoS, clearly not wanting to stand out very much.

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3272995&page=3&postnum=7

very quick to ask for a deadline...perhaps hoping that any lynch could go ahead without giving the person much time to defend themselves, this would be a mafia tactic.

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3273206&page=3&postnum=11

unable to do your night action? could be a trick to make us think he cant be mafia as they got a kill last night?


ArkZero

humour me, have you anything to add to these actions? (i.e. a good explenation of them)

At your first point, I already said in that post GodOfWar_3ever seemed suspicious because of the comments he has made. I didnt have the intention to bandwagon FoS on him as I only FoSed him cause I think that he had to support his votes by giving reasons and not adding some random percentages of being mafia. I could have voted for him, but I think that he may be confused as this his first game, so I gave him another chance.

Also, I didnt want to stand out cause the last three days I havent had a lot of free time, therefore I wouldnt be answering some of the questions you could have asked me. This also applies to the deadline, as wanted to make sure I would be available when the day ends. And for the last point, I dont think that could a trick as I just said I wouldnt like to miss the night.



SciFiBoy on 24 March 2010
ArkZero said:
SciFiBoy said:

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3271912&page=3&postnum=6

not been around for ages...returns purely to bandwagon FoS, clearly not wanting to stand out very much.

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3272995&page=3&postnum=7

very quick to ask for a deadline...perhaps hoping that any lynch could go ahead without giving the person much time to defend themselves, this would be a mafia tactic.

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/post.php?post=3273206&page=3&postnum=11

unable to do your night action? could be a trick to make us think he cant be mafia as they got a kill last night?


ArkZero

humour me, have you anything to add to these actions? (i.e. a good explenation of them)

At your first point, I already said in that post GodOfWar_3ever seemed suspicious because of the comments he has made. I didnt have the intention to bandwagon FoS on him as I only FoSed him cause I think that he had to support his votes by giving reasons and not adding some random percentages of being mafia. I could have voted for him, but I think that he may be confused as this his first game, so I gave him another chance.

Also, I didnt want to stand out cause the last three days I havent had a lot of free time, therefore I wouldnt be answering some of the questions you could have asked me. This also applies to the deadline, as wanted to make sure I would be available when the day ends. And for the last point, I dont think that could a trick as I just said I wouldnt like to miss the night.

did you miss night 1 or not?



zexen_lowe on 25 March 2010

Since this seems dead, I'm gonna put a deadline. I'm ending this in 12 hours, so calculate that in your time




insomniac17 on 25 March 2010

Okay, so... GodOfWar! Come here and explain this post. Yes, it was a mistake. But when you posted this, you  had one vote for you. You weren't in any danger of being lynched. So why were you pretty sure you were getting lynched for that?



Latest News/Discussion for Star Wars: Rebels and Star Wars: The Clone Wars!


GodOfWar_3ever on 25 March 2010
insomniac17 said:

Okay, so... GodOfWar! Come here and explain this post. Yes, it was a mistake. But when you posted this, you  had one vote for you. You weren't in any danger of being lynched. So why were you pretty sure you were getting lynched for that?

I'm pretty sure I'll be lynched because a lot of you posted that yo suspect me. + the REAL mafia will lynch me off because its a golden opportunity for them...