While the fun one has with any game is subjective, most gamers who have played all Halo titles seem to agree that, at least when it comes to the campaign mode, the original Halo (Combat Evolved) is still the best.

Now, a lot of the impressions I´m reading on Reach all say things like "this is bound to be the best campaign since the original Halo", or even say it´ll surpass it.

Based on what you´ve seen and read so far, do you think you could make a (educated) guess as to whether or not Reach´s campaign will in fact be the best since Halo 1? 

moawh I liked the campaign of Halo 2 more only the end was such a fucking cliffhanger Q_Q

I agree that Halo 1 had the best campaign. And I think Reach will have the best campaign once it is released.

i liked Halo 1's campaign because it was something new like when i first saw the halo i was "wow" and when i first did the other stuff.
but Halo 2's campaign was more fun with the Covenant missions too.

i think Halo Reach will be like ODST.

I think your wrong...

Anyways the way its looking I think Halo: Reach will have the best campaign in any Halo to date.

Halo 1 was great in its simplicity, add a couple of revelations along the way and it remained interesting till the very end. Halo 2 and especially Halo 3 just wanted to be too complex for their own good. Reach looks like it will go back to basics but so far the characters I've seen are very unappealing.

I agree that CE has a vastly better campaign than any other Halo by miles and miles and miles.

The rest of the Halo's have been redundant of that first game. I feel that a sequel should never copy its predecessor, and that the redundant Halos were just more of the same. It's kind of like New Vegas. I LOVED Fallout 3, and I also love Fallout 2, but I don't want new Vegas to be just like Fallout 3 anymore than I want it to be like Fallout 2, I want it to build off the previous Fallout games and deliver something new. Same thing with Reach. It needs to step it up in the campaign department this time around, because Halo could broaden its already sizable audience.

Could you explain that? Like ODST in what way?

We will see

Halo 2 is the climax, we can only hope they put effort into this campaign