Dude Alan Wake is not even out yet, It could be great, or it could suck monkey balls, we don't know yet. Do this thread in 6-8 weeks.

it still was a successful sequel no matter how you put it.

@BW_JP

I forgot to add this on my original post:

Please do explain how Alan Wake is unsuccessful. The game still haven't been released yet and it's currently settled on an 84 on meta. let's just wait for its release before dooming it.

It won't sell enough to be a launch title, I'm expecting another Halo or an old series to come back like PGR.

well it got a few like different scores some sites have gave it a 10 9 8.4 so it diff scores ...... and so what if it not even out yet it will at least sell better then too human did and as a example little big planet when it was released it was selling poorly until sony did the re releases and then it started selling so were see how alan wake sells me personally think microsoft will be glad how this new ip sells

and i said in another comment alan wake 2 a couple other first party exclusives would be great at launch of the next xbox