Sorry if any lists are messed up. 

These are the games that will sell 500,000 by year's end that have released from 9/1-12/31.

360:
Halo 3
Eternal Sonata
Skate
Project Gotham Racing 4
Lost Odyssey
Half-Life 2: The Orange Box
MotoGP 07
Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
Virtua Fighter 5
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Assassin's Creed
Rock Band
Mass Effect
pro evolution soccer
Medal Of Honor Airborn
Guitar Hero 3
Fifa 2008
Stranglehold
Tony Hawk's Proving Ground
WWE: Smackdown VS Raw 2008
Need For Speed ProStreet

ps3:
Heavenly Sword
Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction
SingStar
Unreal Tournament 3
Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
Time Crisis 4
SOCOM: Confrontation
Wipeout HD
Gran Turismo 5 Proluge
Medal Of Honor Airborn
pro evolution soccer
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Assassin's Creed
Rock Band
Half-Life 2: The Orange Box
Skate
Guitar Hero 3
Fifa 2008
Tony Hawk's Proving Ground
WWE: Smackdown VS Raw 2008
Need For Speed ProStreet

wii:
Mysims
Guitar Hero 3
Zack & Wiki
Super Mario Galaxy
Rayman: Raving Rabbids 2
Mario & Sonic At The Olympic Games
Resident Evil: Umbrella Chronicles
 

Wii: None

PS3 (1):

 360 (3): 

No, jimmay is a PS360 fanatic.

Opinions?

NE1!!

Didn't realize that so many Wii games had sold over 500,000, that's pretty good. Although I'm very confused as to why you have SSBB on the list, as it's been delayed till next year.

It's jimmay's predictions before SSBB got delayed. Basically he had every PS360 game you could name pegged to sell 500k, and spent pages upon pages arguing that few Wii games would sell in comparison. He's also the kid that was in denial about Heavenly Sword being a short game and kept redirecting his arguments to Halo 3.

WTF, this thread is a joke, reading comprehension for the loss. dtewi, you have completely misunderstood what i said in the first place and have spectaculary got it wrong. I was going to make my thread about this at the end of the year then update it as time goes on (and i still will) but you've jumped in with the wrong data.

WHAT I SAID WAS:

Prediciton 1 - of all the games released between the 1st of september till the 31st of december using gamerankings as the overall review score source both the 360 and the ps3 will have more games rated over 80% than the wii will.

Prediction 2 - of all the games released between the 1st of september till the 31st of december both the 360 and ps3 will have more games that go on to sell over 500,000 than the wii will worldwide. So for example a game could be released in october 2007 and it might take a year for it sell over 500,000 but that will still count as that game selling over 500,000. Also multiformat games are counted as individual formats, so if fifa 2008 sells over 500,000 EACH on the 360 and ps3 but less than 500,000 on the wii then fifa only counts for the 360 and ps3, not the wii.

As i clearly said above, only games released between september 1st and december 31st count. So from your list of wii games so far zero games have sold over 500,000 not 16. My first prediction is almost certain to come true and i'll win that prediction by a huge margin. My second predicition is currently true as both the 360 and ps3 between the 1st sep and 31st dec have had more new games that have sold over 500,000 (vgchartz data on europe is slow to update as fifa08 and pro evolution08 have both sold over 500,000 on 360 and ps3).

Oops, sorry didn't see that part. And way to jump to conclusions. I did not say you were right or wrong anywhere. I will admit if I'm wrong so no need to be defensive.

To be fair, nearly every single one of those X360 predictions actually will, or have hit 500k....