Is the Xbox 360 now the undisputed leader in J &W Console RPGs?

[zexen_lowe]

The Mann said:

zexen_lowe said:

Culdcept Saga isn't an RPG (believe me, I played Culdcept in the PS2, great game, but not and RPG). KUF has a Metacritic of 55. Not saying the game is bad, I haven't played it, but it's hard to take into account.
I haven't considered SF3 and Zoids, you may add that.
All I'm saying is that Vesperia appeared once as a 360/PS3 game. The same happened to Eternal Sonata. What happened to that one?
And I don't care if they are timed or not. I haven't got a PS3 or a 360, and won't be getting a PS3 for a long time. I can wait. I still think that it's not a definitive call that the 360 is the JRPG console for this gen. It's too early to say that

 

Well many people dont consider Folklore an RPG either so you could take that off your list also.

 

That's why I posted it was debatable. And I haven't played Folklore, so I can't judge it. But there is no way to think of Culdcept as an RPG. Call it board game, call it turn based strategy, call it card collecting. But don't call it RPG. Folklore certainly has way more RPG elements than Culdcept