The 1UP Show @ E3: Sony, MS, Nintendo

[Bodhesatva]

ckmlb said:
Just check the reviews of the casual games that are being reviewed very well on 1up.com and stop complaining that one guy expressed his opinion of casual games, a guy who isn't going to be reviewing them anyway....

Also if you are so offended by 1up why don't you just avoid it then? Since your opinion of hardcore games is supposedly that they are for teens (Even though you were very excited when the same kind of violent RE game is coming on the Wii) then you should avoid game sites because they are inferior to you.

I didn't say 1up was terrible, I said that guy is engaging in poor journalism. I like 1up, as a whole. I've been an avid EGM reader since I was but a wee lad. That doesn't change the fact that this was shoddy journalism in this particular case.

I wasn't excited about a Resident Evil game coming to the Wii. We already discussed this at great length. I don't own any Resident Evil games, I don't own RE:4 Wii edition, and I have no plans to buy RE: UC, because they arent' games that interest me. Stop lying. I mean that -- stop lying, because I know you read my response.

Lastly, I don't comb 1up constantly looking for flaws or anything. This one was thrust at me! This link was posted on this site, right here, in this very thread. Why are you angry that I commented on it? Obviously that's unfair. Am I only allowed to watch if I agree absolutely with all of their positions?