Still OG Xbox, for essentially the same reasons it destroyed Xbox Series. OG Xbox built and brand. Xbox One came close to ruining it. But credit where credit is due, Xbox One was more a mixed situation compared to Xbox Series. While the built up to the launch was a disaster, the worst in history, with the dumbest, most anti-consumer shit I have ever seen, they did a lot to fix the wrongs. The hardware was overall good, it did have a handful of solid exclusives, they made it backwards compatible with first the Xbox 360, then the OG Xbox. They also added a 4K Blu-ray player to later models. Xbox One X was genuinely a solid upgrade, much more so than the PS4 pro. For better or worse they launched Game Pass, which at least at the time was a decent deal.
The biggest mistake I think (post launch) was deciding to put everything on PC, you need exclusives to keep the brand alive, and even looking at console exclusives, it was just a weak platform compared to the competition. Still 58 million units sold is respectable, and indeed much more than the OG Xbox.







