I don't tend to view it that way about any game when it comes to how much other people like or dislike them.
It's mainly just that people have different preferences.
God of War 2018 and Breath of the Wild got 10's across the board. Everyone loved them, sold a lot, etc.
But for me the overall experience with both was kinda just okay.
And I've enjoyed obscure titles that few people played or enjoyed.
Although some times people don't give a game that they would like a chance, because they don't believe they will.
And we some times see that with sales for a series suddenly exploding after a certain entry, and older titles in that series get boosted sales or Remakes, etc.
But I don't think that's necessarily the faul of the market, but perhaps more about how the developers/publishers decided to market it. Or that some games are just more difficult to market than others, and it's not really anyone's fault there.
