I rarely ever replay games except for a few, these days almost never. Metal Gears, Resident Evils, and The Uncharted games are rare exceptions. Already beat the RE4 remake 9 times back to back. Loved that game, and was pleasantly surprised how good it was when compared to the original. I generally recommend people to play both versions of the game.
I have real open world fatigue and once I get those platinum, the game goes in the case and on the self. While some of them are very good, many of them feel like actual work to me with repetitive simple tasks and over all bloatage. So game length is a major factor in replaying games. None of those "that one part" segments. All thriller no filler is a big factor here. NG+ rarely offers anything of value to me. Though games that require different storylines/playthroughs are a bit different. I consider completing all of them as part of beating the game. I enjoy seeking new experiences within the video game medium.
