Yes, I would have.
Their digital plans were a big deal for me, and I was looking forward to it. Their plan to be able to share your library (like Steam) with my kids was a game changer (I have four kids). And I do not resell or buy used games, so it was a net gain for me.
DRM has never been an issue for me; I mean, in 20 years, I can count on my fingers the times I wanted to play when their servers were not available (it did happen more than that, but not enough to affect me), and I do not think not being able to play one time or two per years is a big deal.
Furthermore, even today, I always set my main console in my living room so even if Internet is down; my kids can play all my games anyway.