For me personally, it would be the Saturn. Funny thing is I rented both the Saturn and the PS1 from my local video rental store, each for a week. I could not figure out which one I liked better, so I bought neither system. A year later, my boss sold me his PS1, that he got for his girlfriend, for cheap money. I will tell you that if he had bought her a Saturn, I'm sure I would have ended up with that console instead.