Honestly, yeah. He did a great job at reversing a lot of the terrible decision making made by Don Mattrick that took years to undo, but as far as leading Xbox into the future, Phil doesn't seem to have a cohesive vision, or maybe he's just done a terrible job at conveying anything that resembles a cohesive vision because his PR speak can really be all over the place.
I look forward to the day Sarah Bond takes over.