| HappySqurriel said: First off, show me 1 place where I ever claimed that Super Paper Mario was an RPG! Secondly, I have noticed that every time that someone lists a game for the Wii that is available for another platform in these kinds of discussions it is immediately eliminated because it is a port; at the same time every game that appears on the PC and another HD console is included no matter what. When it comes right down to it, the HD console owners tend to play with the rules to put the Wii at a disadvantage to prove their superiority ... Beyond that, I think it is foolish and unreasonable to set an arbitrary score on gamerankings or metacritic to determine what is meant by quality titles (in particular when we're talking about the diversity of a library). I have yet to meet someone who would argue that a score for a party game (or games designed to appeal to new gamers) is equal to a first person shooter with the same score. To put it another way, few people would argue that a game like Lair or Haze which received scores in the 60% range were quality titles but many people would argue that a game like Mario Party (which also received scores in the 60% range) is a quality title. |
No, it was not you said that. If you read my post again, you will figure out who it was meant to. I don't know what discussions are you talking about. If those were about exclusives, then yes. Multiplatforms do not count. But if a discussion is about LIBRARY, they do count.
Well, of course people have different opinions about what a "quality title" is. That is why it is much easier to use metacritic/gamerankings.
