By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
mZuzek said:

Honestly, I personally think the Pokémon remakes should be listed separately from the originals, I believe I did it like that on my first year of doing this, but then I realized that they were only eating at each other's votes, no one ever voted for both GSC and HGSS, so it was a bit unfair on them.

Conversely, many people vote for both originals and remakes of the Metroid, Final Fantasy, and Resident Evil series. Many people had two RE4's on their lists.

I personally do still think it makes sense to count remakes that closely resemble their parent game together with it though. I don't know whether or not Resident Evil 4 and the Pokémon remakes particularly can be considered different enough though, because I haven't played either, but I guess judging these things might get a bit subjective anyway.