ireadtabloids on 26 November 2023
Not sure if was mentioned in pages 2 or 3, but Sin & Punishment: Star Successor is ineligible. I know because I’m pretty sure I mentioned it in the 2009 poll thread. Edit: Seems I’m the first to mention this in this thread so far.
To replace it in the other section here are some games that I think deserve mention there. I especially loved Super Scribblenauts and Ghost Trick, while Etrian Odyssey III has a cult following that resumed with the HD remaster this year.
My vote went to Super Mario Galaxy 2, but it was closer than I expected.
