By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Jaicee said:

I think Super Smash Bros. Brawl might've literally been the worst option on the entire runoff list of choices, at least in my opinion. It won purely on the Nintendo brand and its commercial success in the Wii era. It won because more people here actually played it than the other games. That's the key. Gamers tend to have pretty good tastes, but only within the framework of titles they've actually played before, so sales totals can play a big role in the outcomes of these votes, fairly or otherwise.

I have no problem with you thinking Brawl was the worst option in the runoff. But I strongly object to your assertion that it won only because of the Nintendo brand and its commercial success. That totally invalidates the opinions of people who voted for the game, myself included, because they genuinely love it.