The game I enjoy most from this list is Zelda a Link to the Past. It get my vote for best of the decade.
From other games not present in the poll I think I only rank Heroes of Might and Magic 3 higher, but that game is more niche. The first Diablo and Starcraft is among personal favorites that might be more influential and deserving of the title.
The first venture into 3D for Mario, Final Fantasy and Zelda had great impact, but i simply do not like playing those titles as much. And Doom that seems likly to take the titel is of my least liked gaming genre of them all.
I feel good about my vote of Zelda aLttP.