Reading IGN's Review.
Positives
- Variety of Spaceships. Customisation of Spaceships.
- Clever Hybridizing of Traditional RPG Skill Unlocks and Elder Scrolls System of Increasing Skills During Use.
- Feeling Like My Character Has Honed Skills Instead of Magically Mastering Them.
- Maybe Best Lockpicking Minigame Ever in an RPG.
- Joys of Piloting a Spaceship.
- Rich Sci-Fi Universe.
- All Sorts of Morally Ambiguous Situations.
- Mystery Story Pays Off.
- Combat Gradually Becomes "Good Enough"
- Immense Amount of Quality Roleplaying Quests and Interesting NPCs.
- Stable for a Big RPG.
- Very Fun Raid Moments in Space/Ship Battles.
- Loot Keeps Combat Interesting.
- Interesting Companions. Fun to Chat.
- Eager to Finish Major Questlines Still.
- Sprawling Universe with Detailed Lore.
- Densely Packed, Stories Around Every Corner.
- Interesting Side Quests.
Negatives
- Stingy Skill Distribution (Can't Get Em All in One Go).
- No Respec System.
- Disjointed Space Travel.
- Too Many Loading Screens.
- Too Much Reliance on Quick Travel.
- Slow Start Overall to Combat/Story.
- Slow Rollout of Essential Abilities.
- Disappointing Powerful Enemies, Easy to Kill.
- Unmemorable Gunplay Without Something Like VATS.
- Too Long to Unlock Certain Upgrades.
- One Part of the Main Quest Being Repetitive (But Enticing and Different Rewards...)
- Wish Bethesda Took Inspiration From Breath of the Wild For Puzzles.
- Generally Visually Different But Barren and Lifeless Worlds.
- Shockingly Bad Inventory Management.
- No Maps (Including Mini-Maps) - Only Shows Points of Interest. Nothing to Guide You Around in Cities Aside From Using Shop Signs.
-
Just doesn't really feel like it matches the score, Lol.
VATS is in Fallout because the gunplay is trash, Lol. VATS helps to hide how poor Fallout's gunplay is, I don't think it is needed in Starfield to make Starfields gunplay memorable. I can understand the criticism of the slow start but RDR2 was forgiven for that, Lol. Some other criticisms make it sound like Starfield is more of a hardcore RPG than previous entries.
I'm on IGN because they're the most popular and the dude gave Fallout 4 a 9.5/10 but Starfield a 7/10, Lol.