I know this is gona sound blasphemous to some here but I still have sekiro at the top of fromsoft games. The fluidity of the combat is just on another level to any game. I felt like elden ring just regressed to the ps3 gen when it comes to combat and it really disapointed me. Hinestly I'm not even at halfway of the game but I did notice the repetitivenes of the game already.
I will also put horizon avove elden ring. For the main reason that coming from zero dawn I felt this game improved in every way I wanted it to and that got me exited as i played. While from elden ring I felt a bad regression and I keep thinking about it as I still play it.
It takes genuine talent to see greatness in yourself despite your absence of genuine talent.