How do we still not have this feature yet?

[eva01beserk]

Hiku said:

One inconvenience that comes to mind when it comes to consoles is that it's generally tedious to type out elaborate messages.
So if I want to write some constructive game feedback, I'd usually do it with my keyboard.

And I do when I care about a game and there's a feedback survey after a Beta test.

Recent example is Guilty Gear: Strive, where they delayed the game based on that feedback, and are now improving things and implementing things that a lot of people asked for.

I think you can often find ways to get feedback to the devs. It's just not streamlined with a quick access button, like OP suggested.
And I think the reason for that is, have you seen the user reviews on Metacritic that are on one extreme end of the other?

I think the more hoops you have to jump through, the more it weeds out the non-serious people who just want to make shitposts.
Those who are passionate about making constructive criticism are more likely to make an effort than the shitposters.

Dont these companies have official sites? How about just incorporate that site into the boc itself? That way it links all your activities while if you want give a score while you played it and later elaborate on the site if you want. Something tells me thats possible already to link the official site to the box. But can you do reviews and other kinds of feedback on those sites? Or can you just buy stuff? I never been on one of those. 

I'm glad you understand. While like you said this could be trouble for fully articled critical feedback without a keyboard. At the very least a score would be facilitated to thouse who are passionate. I think the score might be the most important part. A lot of people don't read the reviews and just go to the score.