h2ohno on 10 March 2021
Black Flag.
The first is by far my favorite setting in the franchise and I wish there was another game there with the improvements seen in 2 and onward. 2 was a huge jump in quality in pretty much every way, Brotherhood and Revelations were good but too much of a retread. I think 3 is underrated in the fandom, but 4 really took things to a new level.
