Next Gen D-pads and fighting games

[Pemalite]

I have never liked the D-pad layout on any of the Xbox controllers, but I do like it on the Playstation controllers, it just feels right... So for platformers, fighting games etc'. I prefer a Playstation controller.
But by that same token, I have always preferred the Analogue stick layout of the Xbox controllers which I prefer for first person shooters.

Obviously I feel most at home with a keyboard and mouse though.